Israel and Migration of High Skilled Workforce: Brain Drain and the Possibility of Replenishing the Market with High-Quality Human Capital

International labor migration is one of the most important elements of the modern global economy. Amid growing knowledge economy, migration of highly skilled specialists plays an increasingly important role. For Israel, as an immigrant society, migration issues have been of paramount importance since the early days of the independent state. However, in the first decades the discussion focused mainly around the influence of immigrants on the economic development of the country and identification of the most effective ways to adapt immigrants. At present, the Israeli economic model is built in such a way that the institutions of the knowledge economy are at its core, that requires a significant amount of labor with an appropriate level of skills. At the same time, today Israel witnesses emigration of such specialists, mainly to the United States. This paper is devoted to the analysis of the current situation. The article substantiates the relevance of the chosen topic not only for Israel, but also for other economically developed countries and gives a brief bibliographic review in the field. Next, the author analyzes the tendencies of high skilled work force immigration to Israel at the present stage through the analysis of the supply and demand in the country's labor market in the high-tech sector and assessment of the government programs created to attract foreign non-Jewish specialists to the country which appear to be not effective. The article also deals with the problems of emigration of high skilled workers from Israel. An overview of the magnitude of the phenomenon is given based on international comparisons; main reasons of the trend are identified and analyzed; government programs for the return of compatriots are assessed. It is argued that Israel should pursue a more effective policy to attract highly skilled non-Jewish immigrants into the country, which will fully realize the existing positive externalities and dampen the problem of brain drain.

1. Bahar D. 2018. Migrants and the Startup Nation: Addressing Israel’s Growing Demand for Skills By Increasing the Country’s Role in the World. Policy Brief. Brookings.

2. Ben-David D. 2019. Azivat HaAretz HaMuvtakhat. Mabat Al Atgar haHagira MeIsrael. Mehkarey Shoresh, May 2019.

3. Gould E.D., Moav O. 2007. Israel’s Brain Drain Israel Economic Review. No. 1. Vol. 5. Pp. 1-22.

4. Madadim leMada, leTechnologia, veleHadshanut beIsrael: Tashtit Netunim Hashvaatit. 2016. Haifa: Samuel Neaman Institute.

5. Razin A. 2018a. A. Israel’s Immigration Story: Winners and Losers Israel Economic Review. 2018. No. 1. Vol. 15. Pp. 73-106. www.doi.org/10.3386/w24283

6. Razin A. 2018b. Israel and The World Economy. The Power of Globalization. The MIT Press. 232 p. www.doi.org/10.7551/mitpress/11350.001.0001

7. Razin A., Sadka E. Suwankiri B. 2010. Migration and the Welafare State: Political-Economy Policy Formation. MIT Press. 169 p.

8. Rosenberg D. 2018. Israel’s Technology Economy. Origins and Impact. Palgrave Macmillan. www.doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-76654-6

9. Maryasis D.A. 2007. Uchastiye Izrailya v mezhdunarodnoy migratsii rabochey sily, 19852005 gg. (Israel’s Participation in International Labor Migration, 1985-2005). Gosudarstvo Izrail': politika, ekonomika, obshchestvo. Sbornik statey (The State of Israel: Politics, Economy, Society. Collection of Articles), Institute of the Middle East of RAS. Mosco,. Pp. 114-133. (in Russian)

10. Maryasis D.A. 2015. Opyt postroyeniya ekonomiki innovatsiy. Primer Izrailya (Experience in Building an Economy of Innovation. The Example of Israel). Moscow: Institute of Oriental Studies of RAS. 268 p. (in Russian)

11. Masyukova I.V. 2016a. Yevrei v SSSR: immigratsiya v Izrail' v 1970-kh gg. (na primere yevreyskoy obshchiny Gruzii) (Jews in the USSR: Immigration to Israel in the 1970s (Case of the Jewish Community of Georgia)). Yevrei Yevropy i Blizhnego Vostoka: traditsiya i sovremennost'. Istoriya, yazyki, literatura. Materialy mezhdunarodnoy nauchnoy konferentsii 17 aprelya 2016 g. (Jews of Europe and the Middle East: Tradition and Modernity. History, languages, literature. Proceedings of the International Scientific Conference on April 17, 2016). St. Petersburg. Pp. 294-299. (in Russian)

12. Masyukova I.V. 2016b. Yevreyskaya immigratsiya v Palestinu v kontekste Vtoroy mirovoy voyny (Jewish Immigration to Palestine in the Context of the Second World War). Palestina i Izrail' ot Vtoroy mirovoy voyny do nashikh dney (Palestine and Israel from World War II to the Present Day). Moscow: Institute of Oriental Studies of RAS. Pp. 119-133. (in Russian)

13. Nikitina G.S. 1968. Gosudarstvo Izrail (State of Israel). Moscow, Nauka. 416 p. (in Russian)

14. Satanovskiy E.Ya. 1999. Ekonomika Izrailya v 90-ye gody (The Economy of Israel in the 90’s). Moscow: Institute for the Study of Israel and the Middle East of RAS, Institute of Oriental Studies of RAS. 218 p. (in Russian)

15. Semenchenko N.A. 2002a. Izrail'skaya politika immigratsii i absorbtsii (Israeli Policy of Immigration and Absorption). – Immigratsionnaya politika zapadnykh stran: al'ternativy dlya Rossii (Immigration Policy of Western Countries: Alternatives for Russia). Moscow. Pp. 96-129. (in Russian)

16. Semenchenko N.A. 2002b. Immigratsiya 1990-kh godov v Izrail': nekotoryye osobennosti (Immigration of the 1990s to Israel: Some Feature). Vostok. No. 3. Pp. 97-104. (in Russian)

17. Fedorchenko A.V. 1998. Ekonomika pereselencheskogo obshchestva (Economy of Resettlement Society). Moscow: Institute of the Middle East of RAS. 380 p. (in Russian)

18. Fedorchenko A.V., Mar'yasis D.A. 2006. Nauchno-tekhnicheskiy kompleks Rossii i Izrailya: vozmozhnosti vzaimodeystviya (Scientific and Technical Complex of Russia and Israel: Interaction Opportunities). Analiticheskiye doklady. No. 7 (12). Center for Middle Eastern Studies of the Scientific Coordination Council for International Studies, MGIMO University. (in Russian)

19. Yakimova E.A. 2019. Tekhnologii v obmen na mir: 60-letiye agentstva po razvitiyu mezhdunarodnogo sotrudnichestva (MASHAV) (Technology in Exchange for Peace: the 60 th Anniversary of the Agency for the Development of International Cooperation (MASHAV)). Gosudarstvo Izrail': put' dlinoyu v 70 let: monografiya (The State of Israel: A 70-year Path: a monograph). Ed. by T.A. Karasova, A.V. Fedorchenko. Moscow: MGIMO University. Pp. 92-103. (in Russian)