Proclamation of the All-Russian Empire – the Beginning of the Way to the Great Power Status
https://doi.org/10.24833/2071-8160-2022-2-83-51-68
Abstract
Many historians believe that Russia became a great power either as a result of the Poltava victory in 1709, or after the Nystadt Peace of 1721. It is difficult to agree with this. Peter the Great’s rule indeed produced a combat-ready regular army, a guard, an officer corps, a navy with shipyards, military bases, and coastal artillery. There was an upsurge in the metallurgical industry and mining. Schools with high-quality military and secular education, the Academy of Sciences, the Senate, and the Synod were established. St. Petersburg was founded. Talented and enterprising individuals were promoted to military, diplomatic and administrative posts. The main factor in the rise of the state was military modernization. The main geopolitical achievement of Peter I was the conquest of full access to the Baltic Sea. However, a limited resource base, military and diplomatic defeats and setbacks did not allow Russia to rise to the rank of a great power. The disasters of Narva in 1700 and on the Prut River in 1711 were painful. Russia lost access to the Sea of Azov, the city of Azov, city of Taganrog, the Azov squadron, shipyards and shipbuilding in the Voronezh Territory were lost. The damage from three treatises with the Ottomans in 1711-1713 was great. Russia has lost all of Zaporozhye. The demarcation of the borders of 1714 threw Russia back several hundred kilometers from the Black Sea region. In 1719, the Russian military force was squeezed out of Central Europe – from Mecklenburg. The sphere of influence of Russia after the victorious Peace of Nystad in 1721 was established only in Northern and Eastern Europe – in the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth, the Swedish and Danish-Norwegian kingdom, partly in Prussia. The tsar had no claims to hegemony in Europe and no claims to join the circle of the then great powers. Russia was not a great power like the Habsburg monarchy, France, Great Britain, and the Eurasian-African Ottoman Empire. Russia could not compare with the great powers of that time neither in terms of economic (industrial, financial) power, nor in terms of the intensity of expansionism. The entry of the Russian Empire into the system of international relations as one of the five great powers – France, Great Britain, Austria, Prussia, and Russia – occurred during the Seven Years War of 1756-1763. Another rise to great power took place during the reign of Catherine II. The apogee of greatness and the culmination of Russia's influence on European affairs was the Congress of Vienna in 1814-1815.
About the Author
V. A. Artamonov
Institute of Russian History RAS
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Vladimir A. Artamonov – Candidate of Historical Sciences, Senior Researcher
117292 Moscow, st. D.M. Ulyanova, 19
References
1. Anderson M.S. 1970. Russia under Peter the Great and the Changed Relations of East and West. The New Cambridge modern History. Cambridge. Vol. 6. P. 716–740.
2. Beyrau D. 1984. Militär und Gesellschaft im vorrevolutionären Russland. Köln,Wien, 504 S. (In German)
3. Danilović V. 2002. When the Stakes are High: Deterrence and Conflict among Major Powers. The University of Michigan Press. 281 p.
4. Krokosz Р. 2020. Armia Piotra I gwarantem mocarstwowej pozycji Rosji w Europie. Studia z Dziejów Rosji i Europy Środkowo-Wschodniej. Warszawa, T. LV. S. 9–49. (In Polish)
5. Wittram R. 1964. Peter I, Czar und Kaiser. Göttingen. Bd. 2. 646 S. (In German)
6. Ageeva O.G. 1999. Imperatorskij status Rossii: k istorii politicheskogo mentaliteta russkogo obshchestva nachala XVIII veka [Russian Imperial Status: towards the History of the Political Mentality of Russian Society at the Beginning of the 18 Century]. Tsar' i tsarstvo v russkom obshchestvennom soznanii. Moscow. Vol. 2. P. 112-140. (In Russian)
7. Anisimov M.Yu. 2021. Rossiya i mezhdunarodnye kongressy v carstvovanie Elizavety Petrovny [Russia and International Congresses in the Reign of Elizabeth Petrovna]. Rossiya na mezhdunarodnyh forumah i kongressah XVII – nachala XX veka. Moscow. P. 131–181. (In Russian)
8. Artamonov V.A. 1990. Rossiya i Rech' Pospolitaya posle Poltavskoj pobedy (1709–1714) [Russia and the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth after the Poltava Victory (1709-1714)]. Moscow. 212 p. (In Russian)
9. Artamonov V.A. 2019. Turecko-russkaya vojna 1710–1713 [The Turkish-Russian War of 1710-1713]. Moscow. 447 p. (In Russian)
10. Bobylev V.S. 1990. Vneshnyaya politika Rossii epohi Petra I [Foreign Policy of Russia in the Era of Peter I]. Moscow. 167 p. (In Russian)
11. Borisov N.S. 2006. Ivan III [Ivan III]. 3-e izd. Moscow. 643 p. (In Russian)
12. Brandenburg N.E. 1876. Materialy dlya istorii artillerijskogo upravleniya v Rossii [Materials for the History of Artillery Management in Russia]. Prikaz artillerii (1701–1720). Saint Petersburg. 571 p. (In Russian)
13. Brandenburg N.E. 1889. 500-letie russkoj artillerii (1389–1889) [500th Anniversary of the Russian Artillery (1389-1889)]. Saint Petersburg. 118 p. (In Russian)
14. Cernak K. 1993. Konec epohi velikih derzhav v evropejskoj politike [The End of the Era of the Great Powers in European Politics]. Voprosy istorii. No5. P. 41–50. (In Russian)
15. Cesel'skij T. 2014. Rech' Pospolitaya i baltijskaya ekspansiya Rossijskoj imperii v XVIII v. [The Polish – Lithuanian Commonwealth and the Baltic Expansion of the Russian Empire in the 18 Century]. Peterburgskie slavyanskie i balkanskie issledovaniya. No1. P. 118–144. (In Russian)
16. Cнerkasov P.P. 1995. Dvuglavyj oryol i korolevskie lilii. Stanovlenie russko-francuzskih otnoshenij v XVIII v. 1700–1775. [Double-headed Eagle and Royal Lilies. Formation of RussianFrench Relations in the 18th Century. 1700-1775]. Moscow. 438 P. (In Russian)
17. Degoev V.V. 2021. Severnaya vojna 1700–1721 gg. i russkaya diplomatiya [The Northern War of 1700-1721 and Russian Diplomacy]. Moscow. 655 p. (In Russian)
18. Dostyan I.S. 1995. Problema sozdaniya nezavisimyh gosudarstv grekov i yuzhnyh slavyan v russko-balkanskih obshchestvenno-politicheskih svyazyah (konec XVIII – pervaya tret' XIX v.) [The Problem of the Creation of Independent States of Greeks and South Slavs in Russian-Balkan Socio-Political Relations (Late 18th – First Third of the 19th Century)]. Rossiya i Balkany: iz istorii obshchestvenno-politicheskih i kul'turnyh svyazej (XVIII v. – 1878g.). Moscow. P. 41–80. (In Russian)
19. Eliseeva O.I. 2000. Geopoliticheskie proekty G.A.Potyomkina [Potemkin's Geopolitical Projects]. Moscow. 341 p. (In Russian)
20. Eliseeva O.I. 2011. Geopoliticheskie proekty carstvovaniya Ekateriny II [Geopolitical Projects of the Reign of Catherine II]. Rossijskaya imperiya ot istokov do nachala 19 veka. Ocherki social'no-politicheskoj i ekonomicheskoj istorii. Moscow. P. 745–759. (In Russian)
21. Fejgina S.A. 1959. Alandskij kongress. Vneshnyaya politika Rossii v konce Severnoj vojny [Aland Congress. Russian Foreign Policy at the End of the Northern War]. Moscow. 545p. (In Russian)
22. Ivanyuk S.A. 2014. Malaya vojna v strategii i taktike russkoj armii na pervom etape Severnoj vojny [Small War in the Strategy and Tactics of the Russian Army at the First Stage of the Northern War]. Volgograd. 351 p. (In Russian)
23. Kappeler A. 1997. Rossiya — mnogonacional'naya imperiya. Vozniknovenie. Istoriya. Raspad [Russia is a Multinational Empire. Occurrence. History. Decay]. Moscow. 341 p. (In Russian)
24. Kotova E.V. 2021. Rossiya na Venskom kongresse 1814–1815 gg. [Russia at the Vienna Congress of 1814-1815]. Rossiya na mezhdunarodnyh forumah i kongressah XVII – nachala XX veka. Moscow. P. 222–262. (In Russian)
25. Krotov P.A. 2009. Bitva pri Poltave. K 300-letnej godovshchine [Battle of Poltava. To the 300th Anniversary]. Saint Petersburg. 415 p. (In Russian)
26. Krotov P.A. 2014. Bitva pod Poltavoj. Nachalo Velikoj Rossii [The Battle of Poltava. The Beginning of Great Russia]. Saint Petersburg. 567 p. (In Russian)
27. Krotov P.A. 2017. Rossijskij flot na Baltike pri Petre Velikom [The Russian Fleet in the Baltic under Peter the Great]. Saint Petersburg. 743 p. (In Russian)
28. Kurukin I.V. 2021. Cena pobed: o stoimosti voennyh kampanij v Rossii XVIII v. [The Price of Victories: on the Cost of Military Campaigns in Russia of the 18th Century]. Rossijskaya istoriya. Vol. 4. P. 52–59. DOI: 10.31857/S086956870016247-2 (In Russian)
29. Laskovskij F.F. 1861. Materialy dlya istorii inzhenernogo iskusstva v Rossii [Materials for the History of Engineering Art in Russia.]. Opyt issledovaniya inzhenernogo iskusstva v carstvovanie imperatora Petra Velikogo. Saint Petersburg. 642 p. (In Russian)
30. Liven D. 2007. Rossijskaya imperiya i eyo vragi s XVI veka do nashih dnej [The Russian Empire and its enemies from the 16th Century to the Present Day]. Moscow. 679 p. (In Russian)
31. Markova O.P. 1986. O proiskhozhdenii tak nazyvaemogo Grecheskogo proekta (80-e gody 18 v.) [On the Origin of the So-Called Greek Project (the 80s of the 18th Century)]. Problemy metodologii i istochnikovedeniya vneshnej politiki Rossii. Sb. statej. Moscow. P. 5–46. (In Russian)
32. Melin Y.A., Yuhansson A.V, Hedenborg S. 2002. Istoriya Shvecii [History of Sweden]. Moscow. 399 p. (In Russian)
33. Miller A.I. 2006. Imperiya Romanovyh i nacionalizm. Esse po metodologii istoricheskogo issledovaniya [Romanov Empire and Nationalism. Essay on the Methodology of Historical Research]. Moscow. 316 p. (In Russian)
34. Molchanov N.N. 1984. Diplomatiya Petra Pervogo [Diplomacy of Peter the Great]. Moscow. 438 p. (In Russian)
35. Narochnickaya N.A. 2021. «Vechnyj, istinnyj i nerushimyj...» ["Eternal, True and Indestructible..."]. Nishtadtskij mirnyj dogovor i rozhdenie Rossijskoj imperii 1721-2021. Moscow. P. 3–10. (In Russian)
36. Nelipovich S.G. 2010. Soyuz dvuglavyh orlov. Russko-avstrijskij voennyj al'yans vtoroj chetverti XVIII veka [Union of Double-Headed Eagles. The Russian-Austrian Military Alliance of the Second Quarter of the 18th Century]. Moscow. 406 p. (In Russian)
37. Nikiforov L.A. 1973. Rossiya v sisteme evropejskih derzhav v pervoj chetverti XVIII v. [Russia in the System of European Powers in the First Quarter of the 18th Century]. Rossiya v period reform Petra I. Moscow. P. 9–39. (In Russian)
38. Nikiforov L.A. 1959. Vneshnyaya politika Rossii v poslednie gody Severnoj vojny. Nishtadtskij mir [Russia's Foreign Policy in the Last Years of the Northern War. Nishtadtsky mir]. Moscow. 498 p. (In Russian)
39. Nogaev I.V. 2021. Nishtadtskij mir i principy rossijsko-shvedskih otnoshenij v XVIII veke [Nishtadt Peace and the Principles of Russian-Swedish Relations in the 18th Century]. Nishtadtskij mirnyj dogovor i rozhdenie Rossijskoj imperii 1721–2021. Moscow. P. 112-132. (In Russian)
40. Ot carstva k imperii. Rossiya v sistemah mezhdunarodnyh otnoshenij. Vtoraya polovina XVI – nachalo XX veka [From Kingdom to Empire. Russia in the Systems of International Relations. The Second Half of the 16th – the Beginning of the 20th Century]. 2015. Moscow. 439 p. (In Russian)
41. Pavlenko N.I. 1990. Pyotr Velikij [Peter the Great]. Moscow. 591 p. (In Russian)
42. Peskov A.M. 2007. «Russkaya ideya» i «russkaya dusha» [“Russian Idea" and “Russian Soul" by A.M. Peskov. Essays of Russian historiosophy]. Ocherki russkoj istoriosofii. Moscow. 104 p. (In Russian)
43. Redin D.A. 2021. Imperiya Petra Velikogo: kurs – vest, veter vstrechnyj [The Empire of Peter the Great: the Course is West, the Wind is Oncoming]. Rossijskaya istoriya. No4. P. 3–22. DOI: 10.31857/S086956870016252-8 (In Russian)
44. Sanin G.A. 2021a. Rossiya na Utrekhtskom i Braunshveyajsgskom kongressah 1713 g. Nishtadskij mir 1721 goda [Russia at the Utrecht and Brunswick Congresses of 1713. The Peace of Nishtadt of 1721]. Rossiya na mezhdunarodnyh forumah i kongressah XVII – nachala XX veka. Moscow. P. 85–130. (In Russian)
45. Sanin G.A. 2021b. Pyotr I – diplomat. Velikoe posol'stvo i Nishtadtskij mir [Peter I is a Diplomat. The Great Embassy and the Nishtadt Peace]. Nishtadtskij mirnyj dogovor i rozhdenie Rossijskoj imperii 1721–2021. Moscow. P. 73–111. (In Russian)
46. Velikanov V.S. 2011. K voprosu ob organizacii i chislennosti russkoj armii v Narvskom pohode 1700 goda [On the Question of the Organization and Number of the Russian Army in the Narva Campaign of 1700]. Vojna i oruzhie. Novye issledovaniya i materialy. Saint Petersburg. T. 1. P. 130–142. (In Russian)
47. Velikanov V.S. 2020. Rugodivskij pohod i srazhenie pod Narvoj 19(30) noyabrya 1700 g. [Rugodivsky Campaign and the Battle of Narva on November 19 (30), 1700]. Moscow. 191 p. (In Russian)
48. Velikanov V.S., Lobin A.N. 2012. Russkaya artilleriya v Narvskom pohode 1700 g. [Russian Artillery in the Narva Campaign of 1700]. Voenno-istoricheskij zhurnal «Staryj Cejhgauz». Moscow. No48. P. 3–11. (In Russian)
49. Zutis, Ya.Ya. 1946. Ostzejskij vopros v XVIII veke [The Ostzei Question in the 18th Century]. Riga. 649 p. (In Russian)
Review
For citations:
Artamonov V.A. Proclamation of the All-Russian Empire – the Beginning of the Way to the Great Power Status. MGIMO Review of International Relations. 2022;15(2):51-68. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.24833/2071-8160-2022-2-83-51-68
Views:
1007
Email this article 