Unsuccessful Peace-making: the Mission of Francesco da Collo and Antonio de Conti to Moscow (1518-1519)
https://doi.org/10.24833/2071-8160-2024-4-97-155-182
Abstract
This article explores the peace mission of Francesco da Collo and Antonio de Conti, envoys of Emperor Maximilian I of the Holy Roman Empire, to Grand Prince Vasily III of Moscow in 1518–1519. The mission aimed to mediate between Moscow and the PolishLithuanian Commonwealth, seeking to align both states for a planned united Christian campaign against the Ottoman Empire, whose expansion in Southeastern Europe posed a serious threat. The study centers on da Collo’s report from the mission, which not only chronicles the negotiations but also provides rare insights into Russian diplomacy and courtly traditions of the early 16th century. The article underscores the critical role of ceremonial practices, such as receptions, banquets, and hunts, in the diplomatic culture of the period.
Particular focus is given to da Collo's accounts of his interactions with Vasily III and his entourage, highlighting the crucial importance of personal meetings and informal contacts in the diplomatic process of the time. Despite the envoys' efforts, the mission achieved only a temporary one-year truce, with insurmountable barriers to a comprehensive peace including territorial disputes—especially over the control of Smolensk—and the issue of repatriating Russian prisoners of war from Poland.
Furthermore, da Collo’s report serves as an early illustration of how Muscovy was constructed as an eastern, despotic power, offering one of the first examples of Russia being depicted as the “Other” in early modern European thought. The study sheds light on the complex dynamics of diplomacy in this era and reveals how these interactions contributed to the broader European perception of Russia as an alien and adversarial state.
About the Author
O. F. Kudriavtsev
Moscow State Lomonosov University
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Oleg F. Kudriavtsev – Doctor of Historical Sciences, Professor, Department of Medieval History
27 Lomonosovskiy prospect (korpus 4), GSP-1, Moscow, Russia, 119991
References
1. Uebersberger H. 1906. Oesterreich und Russland seit dem Ende des 15. Jahrhunderts. Wien; Leipzig: W. Braumuller. 581 s. (in German)
2. Hamel I.H. 1865. Anglichane v Rossii v XVI XVII stoletiyah [The Englishmen in Russia of the XVI XVIIth centuries]. Prilozenie k VIII tomy sapisok Imperatorskoy Akademii Nauk [Supplement to the VIIIth Volume of the Records of the Emperor’s Academy of Sciences]. S.-Petersburg: Tip. Imp. Akad. Nauk. 179 p. (In Russian).
3. Garin E. 1986. Problemi italianskogo Vosrozdenia [The Problems of the Italian Renaissance]. Moskwa: “Progress”. 495 p. (In Russian).
4. Gralya I. 1992. Motivi “Orshanskogo triumfa” v yagellonskoy propagande [The Motives of the “Orsha’s Triumpf” in the Jagellonian Propaganda]. Problemi russkoy istorii I kulturi feodalisma [The Problems of the Russian History and Culture of the Feudalism]. Moscow, P. 46-50. (In Russian).
5. Zimin A.A. 1972. Rossia na poroge Novogo vremeni (Ocherk politicheskoy istorii Rossii pervoy treti XVI veka) [Russia in the Beginning of the New Times (Essays of the Political History of Russia of the First Third of the XVIth century)]. Moskwa: “Nauka”. 452 p. (In Russian).
6. Karamsin N.M. 1842. Istoria gosudarstwa Rossiyskogo [The History of the Russian State]. Book II. Vol. VII. Moskwa: V tipografii Eduarda Praza. 526 p. (In Russian).
7. Klyuchevskiy V.O. 2023. Skasaniya inostrantsev o Moskovskom gosudarstve [The Foreign Records Dedicated Moscovite State]. Moskwa: “Yurayt”. 286 p. (1 Ed. – Moscow, 1866). (In Russian).
8. Kudriavtsev O.F. 1997. Zhisn’ za tsarya: russkie v vospriyatii evropeitsev pervoy polovini XVI veka [A Life for the Tzar: the European’s Perception of Russians in the First Half of the XVIth Century]. Rossiya v pervoy polovine XVI veka: vsglyad is Evropi [Russia in the First Half of the XVIth Century: a Glance from Europe]. Prepared by O.F. Kudriavtsev. Moscow: “Russkiy mir”. P. 6-34. (In Russian).
9. Kudriavtsev O.F. 2008. Florentiyskaya Platonovskaya akademiya. Ocherk istorii duhovnoy zisni renessansnoy Italii [The Florentine Platonic Academy. An Essay in the History of Intellectual Life of the Renaissance Italy]. Moskwa: “Nauka”. 478 p. (In Russian).
10. Pisarevskiy G. 1895. K istorii snosheniy Rossii s Germaniey v nachale XVI veka [About the History of the Relations between Russia and Germany in the Beginning of the XVIth Century]. Chteniya v obzestwe istorii I drevnostey rossiyskih [The Records of the Society of Russian History and Antiquities]. Book 2. P. 1-21. (In Russian).
11. Revyakina N.V. 2000. Chelovek v gumanisme italianskogo Vosrozdeniya [A Man in the Italian Renaissance Humanism]. Ivanovo: Isd-vo Ivanovskogo universiteta. 323 p. (In Russian).
12. Rossiya v pervoy polovine XVI veka: vsglyad is Evropi [Russia in the First Half of the XVIth Century: a Glance from Europe] / Prepared by O.F. Kudriavtsev. Moskwa: “Russkoe slovo”. 1997. 403 p. (In Russian).
13. Skrsinskaya E.Ch. 1971. Barbaro I Contarini o Rossii. K istorii italo-russkih svyasey v XV veke [Barbaro and Contarini on Russia. To the History of Italo-Russain Relations in the XVth Century]. Leningrad: Nauka. 273 p. (In Russian).
14. Sinitsyna N.V. 1977. Maxim Grek v Rossii [Maximos the Greek in Russia]. Moskwa: Nauka. 332 p. (In Russian).
15. Sinitsyna N.V. 1997. Dva mira: vosmoznosti vsaimoponimaniya [Two Worlds: the Possibilities of the Mutual Understanding]. Rossiya v pervoy polovine XVI veka: vsglyad is Evropi [Russia in the First Half of the XVIth Century: a Glance from Europe]. Prepared by O.F. Kudriavtsev. Moskwa. P. 35-62. (In Russian).
16. Sobolevskiy A.I. 1903. Perevodnaya literatura Moskovskoy Rusi. Bibliograficheskiye materiali [The Literature Translations of Moscovite Russia, the XIV-XVII Centuries. The Bibliographical Materials]. Sbornik otdeleniya russkogo yasika I literature Imperatorskoy akademii nauk [The Collection of Works of the Department of the Russian Language and Literature of the Emperor’s Academy of Sciences]. S.-Petersburg: Tip. Imp. Akad. Nauk. Vol. 74. N 1. 460 p. (In Russian).
17. Soloviev S.M. 1989. Sochineniya [The Works]. Moskwa: “Misl’”. 783 p. Book III. (In Russian).
18. Choroshkevich A.L. 1980. Russkoe gosudarstwo v sisteme mezdunarodnih otnosheniyah konza XV -nachala XVI vekov [The Russian State in the International Relations of the End of the XVth and the Beginning of the XVIth centuries]. Moskwa: “Nauka”. 295 p. (In Russian).
19. Choroshkevich A.L. 2008. Sigismund Herberstein I ego Sapiski o Moskowii [Sigismund Herberstein and His Rerum Moscoviticarum Commentarii]. Herberstein S. Sapiski o Moskowii [Herberstein S. Rerum Moscoviticarum Commentarii]. Moskwa: Pamyatniki istoricheskoy misli. Vol. II. P. 7-258. 295 p. (In Russian).
20. Shmurlo E.F. 1937. Rim I Moskwa. Nachalo snosheniy Moskowskogo gosudarstwa s Papskim prestolom (1462-1528). [Rome and Moscow. The Beginning of the Relations of the Moscovite State with the Popes (1462-1528)]. Sapiski russkogo istoricheskogo obschestwa v Prage. Praga Cheshskaya; Narva [The Records of the Russian Historical Society in Prague]. Prague; Narva: Tiskla knihtiskarna Petra Dusca v Ricanech. Book 3. P. 91-136. (In Russian).
21. Simchich O. 1996. Diplomaticheskaya missiya posla Maximiliana I Francesco da Collo I ego “Relazione di Moscovia” [The Diplomatic mission of Maximilianus’ the I Ambassador Francesco da Collo and His “Relazione di Moscovia”]. Francesco da Collo. Donoshenie o Moskovii [Francesco da Collo. “Relazione di Moscovia”]. Moskwa: “Nasledie”. P. 5-43.
Review
For citations:
Kudriavtsev O.F. Unsuccessful Peace-making: the Mission of Francesco da Collo and Antonio de Conti to Moscow (1518-1519). MGIMO Review of International Relations. 2024;17(4):155-182. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.24833/2071-8160-2024-4-97-155-182
Views:
678
Email this article 