Systems approach in the Soviet IR Theory: The Sources and Consequences of a Tacit Scientific Revolution
https://doi.org/10.24833/2071-8160-2025-1-100-66-99
Abstract
This article examines the intellectual foundations, rationale, and evolution of the systemic approach in Soviet international relations (IR) theory throughout the 1970s and 1980s. This topic has gained increasing relevance in contemporary debates on the theoretical foundations of Russian international political thought. The study demonstrates that the emergence of the systemic approach was a response to the theoretical anomalies encountered by Marxism-Leninism in explaining global developments following the Second World War. The weakening of inter-imperialist struggles, the persistence of capitalism, and the growing contradictions within the socialist bloc posed significant challenges to Marxist-Leninist explanatory frameworks. The transformation of the dominant paradigm into an ideological dogma did not prevent a scientific revolution; however, this transformation occurred covertly, with radical revisions masked as superficial reinterpretations of doctrine.
The systemic approach in Soviet IR rested on three principal intellectual foundations: the reinterpretation of Marxist-Leninist tenets, engagement with Western—primarily Realist—theories, and the incorporation of terminology from general systems theory. Elgiz Pozdnyakov and Mark Khrustalev played a central role in its development. To navigate ideological constraints, these theorists maintained a high level of abstraction in their analytical framework, thereby avoiding explicit accusations of ideological deviation. Despite these constraints, they developed an original theoretical model that, in some respects, anticipated later insights in Western scholarship. However, its limited influence on applied policy analysis and official Soviet discourse in the 1980s suggests that the systemic approach produced non-trivial conclusions that were politically inconvenient.
About the Author
I. A. Istomin
MGIMO University
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Igor A. Istomin — Cand. Science (Political), Head of the Department of Applied Analysis of International Problems
76, Vernadskogo avenue, Moscow, 119454, Russian Federation
References
1. Bertalanffy L. von. 1968. General System Theory: Foundations, Development, Applications. New York: George Braziller. 295 p.
2. Cox R. W. 1981. Social Forces, States and World Orders: Beyond International Relations Theory. Millennium. 10(2). P. 126–155.
3. Giddens A. 1984. The Constitution of Society: Outline of the Theory of Structuration. Cambridge: Polity Press. 402 p.
4. Gilpin R. 1981. War and Change in International Politics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 272 p.
5. Hobson J. A. 1902. Imperialism: A Study. London: James Nisbet & Co. 420 p.
6. Kaplan M. A. 1957. System and Process in International Politics. New York: John Wiley and Sons. 318 p.
7. McClelland C. A. 1968. Theory and the International System. London: Macmillan. 354 p.
8. Modelski G. 1962. Comparative International Systems. World Politics. 14(4). P. 662–674.
9. Moravcsik A. 1997. Taking Preferences Seriously: A Liberal Theory of International Politics. International Organization. 51(4). P. 513–553.
10. Morgenthau H. 1948. Politics Among Nations: The Struggle for Power and Peace. New York: Alfred A. Knopf. 668 p.
11. Nye Jr J. S., Keohane R. O. 1971. Transnational Relations and World Politics: An Introduction. International Organization. 25(3). P. 329–349.
12. Ruggie J. G. 1983. Continuity and Transformation in the World Polity: Toward a Neorealist Synthesis. World Politics. 35(2). P. 261–285.
13. Shen Z., Xia Y. 2015. Mao and the Sino–Soviet Partnership, 1945–1959: A New History. Lexington Books. 391 p.
14. Waltz K. 1979. Theory of International Politics. Boston: McGraw-Hill. 251 p.
15. Wendt A. E. 1987. The Agent-Structure Problem in International Relations Theory. International Organization. 41(3). P. 335–370.
16. Berdyaev N.A. 1990. Istoki i smysl russkogo kommunizma [The Origins and Meaning of Russian Communism]. Moscow: Nauka. 220 p. (In Russian)
17. Blauberg I.V., Yudin E.G. 1973. Stanovlenie i sushchnost' sistemnogo podkhoda [Formation and Essence of the System Approach]. Moscow: Nauka. 270 p. (In Russian)
18. Bogaturov A. D. 2000. Desyat' let paradigmy osvoeniya [Ten Years of the Paradigm of Development]. Pro et contra. 5(1). P. 195–201. (In Russian)
19. Bogaturov A.D. 2019. Sistemnaya istoriya mezhdunarodnykh otnosheniy. Opyat razdelenny mir [Systemic History of International Relations. Another Divided World]. Moscow. 362 p. (In Russian)
20. Bogdanov A.A. 1917. Vseobshchaya organizatsionnaya nauka (tektologiya) [Universal Organizational Science (Tektology)]. Saint Petersburg: M.I. Semenov. 255 p. (In Russian)
21. Bukharin N.I. 1918. Mirovoe khozyaystvo i imperializm (ekonomicheskiy ocherk) [World Economy and Imperialism (Economic Essay)]. Petrograd: Priboy. 115 p. (In Russian)
22. Degtereva D. A., Istomina I. A. 2015. Sistemnoe modelirovanie mezhdunarodnykh otnoshenii. [System Modeling of International Relations]. World Economy and International Relations. 11. P. 17–30. (In Russian)
23. Dugin A.G. 1997. Osnovy geopolitiki [Foundations of Geopolitics]. Moscow. 599 p. (In Russian)
24. Emelyanova E. N. 2018. Politika bolshevistskogo rukovodstva po otnosheniyu k Germanii (1918–1919) [The Policy of the Bolshevik Leadership Towards Germany (1918–1919)]. Nauchnyi dialog. 4. P. 227–239. (In Russian)
25. Engels F. 1937. Proiskhozhdenie semyi, chastnoi sobstvennosti i gosudarstva [The Origin of the Family, Private Property and the State]. Moscow: Partizdat. 87 p. (In Russian).
26. Engels F. 1966. Pismo V. Borgiusu, 25.01.1894 [Letter to V. Borgius, January 25, 1894]. Marx K., Engels F. Sochinenii. T. 39 [Works. Vol. 39]. Moscow: Izdatelstvo politicheskoy literatury. P. 174-175. (In Russian)
27. Engels F. 1974. Predislovie k nemetskomu izdaniyu 1883 goda [Preface to the German Edition of 1883]. Marx K., Engels F. Manifest Kommunisticheskoi partii. Moscow: Politizdat. 255 p. (In Russian)
28. Gantman V. I. (ed.). 1976. Sovremennye burzhuaznye teorii mezhdunarodnykh otnoshenii: Kriticheskii analiz [Modern Bourgeois Theories of International Relations: A Critical Analysis]. Moscow: Nauka. 486 p. (In Russian)
29. Gantman V. I. (ed.). 1984. Sistema, struktura i protsess razvitiia sovremennykh mezhdunarodnykh otnoshenii [System, Structure, and Process of the Development of Modern International Relations]. Moscow: Nauka. 422 p. (In Russian)
30. Cherkasov P. 2016. IMEMO: Ocherk istorii [IMEMO: A Historical Essay]. Moscow: Ves mir. 870 p. (In Russian)
31. Gvishiani D.M. 2023. Mosty v budushchee: O zarozhdenii sistemnogo analiza i proryve v predstavleniyakh o nauke i praktike upravleniya v SSSR [Bridges to the Future: On the Emergence of System Analysis and a Breakthrough in the Perception of Science and Management Practice in the USSR]. Moscow: LENAND. 333 p. (In Russian)
32. Khrustalev M. A. 1984. Osnovy teorii vneshnei politiki gosudarstva [Fundamentals of the Theory of Foreign Policy of the State]. Moscow: MGIMO. 80 p. (In Russian)
33. Khrustalev M. A. 1987. Sistemnoe modelirovanie mezhdunarodnykh otnoshenii [System Modeling of International Relations]. Moscow: MGIMO. 115 p. (In Russian)
34. Khrustalev M. A. 2008. Analiz mezhdunarodnykh situatsii i politicheskaia ekspertiza [Analysis of International Situations and Political Expertise]. Moscow: NOFMO. 224 p. (In Russian)
35. Khudolei K. K. 2018. Evolyutsiya idei mirovoi revolyutsii v politike Sovetskogo Soyuza (epokha Kominterna i sotsializma v odnoi strane) [The Evolution of the Idea of World Revolution in Soviet Policy (The Era of the Comintern and Socialism in One Country)]. Vestnik of Saint Petersburg University. International Relations. 10(2). P. 145–165. (In Russian)
36. Kokoshin A.A. 1984. SShA v sisteme mezhdunarodnykh otnosheniy 80-kh godov: Gegemonizm vo vneshney politike Vashingtona [The USA in the International Relations System of the 1980s: Hegemonism in Washington’s Foreign Policy]. Moscow: Mezhdunarodnye otnosheniya. 303 p. (In Russian)
37. Kosolapov N. A. et al. 2021. O popytke sozdaniia teorii mezhdunarodnykh otnoshenii v IMEMO v 1970-e gody [On the Attempt to Create a Theory of International Relations at IMEMO in the 1970s]. Mirovaia ekonomika i mezhdunarodnye otnosheniia. 65(4). P. 80–91. (In Russian)
38. Kuhn T.S. 2009. Struktura nauchnykh revolyutsiy [The Structure of Scientific Revolutions]. Moscow: AST. 317 p. (In Russian)
39. Labetskii O. B. (ed.). 1975. Sotsialisticheskie mezhdunarodnye otnosheniia i ikh kritiki [Socialist International Relations and Their Critics]. Moscow: Mezhdunarodnye otnosheniia. 203 p. (In Russian)
40. Marx K. 1957. 18 brumera Lui Bonaparta [The Eighteenth Brumaire of Louis Bonaparte]. Sochineniya. Izd. 2-e. Vol. 8. Moscow: Gosudarstvennoe izdatelstvo politicheskoy literatury. 126 p. (In Russian)
41. Marx K.1958. Vvedenie (Iz ekonomicheskikh rukopisey 1857–1858 godov) [Introduction (From the Economic Manuscripts of 1857–1858)]. Sochineniya. 2nd Edition.. Vol. 12. Moscow: Politizdat. (In Russian)
42. Marx K. 1935. Klassovaya borba vo Frantsii s 1848 po 1850 [Class Struggles in France from 1848 to 1850]. Moscow: Partizdat TsK VKP(b). 159 p. (In Russian)
43. Mosolov V.G. 2010. IMEL – tsitadel' partiynoy ortodoksii. Iz istorii Instituta marksizma-leninizma pri TsK KPSS, 1921–1956 [IMEL – The Citadel of Party Orthodoxy. From the History of the Institute of Marxism-Leninism under the Central Committee of the CPSU, 1921–1956]. Moscow: Novyy khronograf. (In Russian)
44. Popper K. 1983. Logika nauchnogo issledovaniya. Logika i rost nauchnogo znaniya [The Logic of Scientific Discovery. The Logic and Growth of Scientific Knowledge]. Moscow: Progress. 565 p. (In Russian)
45. Pozdnyakov E.A. 1976. Sistemnyy podkhod i mezhdunarodnye otnosheniya [The System Approach and International Relations]. Moscow: Nauka. 157 p. (In Russian)
46. Podberezkin A.I., Kharkevich M.V. 2015. Mir i voyna v XXI veke: Opyt dolgosrochnogo prognozirovaniya razvitiya mezhdunarodnykh otnosheniy [Peace and War in the 21st Century: Experience of Long-Term Forecasting of the Development of International Relations]. Moscow: MGIMO. (In Russian)
47. Problemy teorii mezhdunarodnykh otnoshenii. 1969. World Economy and International Relations. 9. P. 88–106. (In Russian)
48. Problemy teorii mezhdunarodnykh otnoshenii. 1969. World Economy and International Relations. 11. P. 78–99. (In Russian)
49. Sadovskiy V.N. 1974. Osnovaniya obshchey teorii sistem: Logiko-metodologicheskiy analiz [Foundations of General Systems Theory: Logical and Methodological Analysis]. Moscow: Nauka. (In Russian)
50. Strezhneva M. V. 2020. Sistemnyi podkhod v mezhdunarodnykh issledovaniyakh: ob aktual'nosti teoreticheskogo naslediya Aleksandra Bogdanova [The System Approach in International Studies: On the Relevance of Alexander Bogdanov’s Theoretical Legacy]. Polis. Political Studies. 4. P. 112–123. (In Russian)
51. Trubetskoy N.S. 2010. Ideokratia i proletariat [. Trubetskoy N.S. Izbrannoe [Selected Works]. Moscow: ROSSPEN. 616 p.
52. Tsygankov A.P. 2014. Rossiyskaya teoriya mezhdunarodnykh otnosheniy: kakoy yey byt? [Russian Theory of International Relations: What Should It Be?]. Comparative Politics Russia. 2(15). P. 65–83.
53. Tsygankov A.P. 2018. Russkaya mezhdunarodnaya teoriya: Tri traditsii [Russian International Theory: Three Traditions]. Moscow: Russcience. 332 p. (In Russian)
54. Tsygankov A.P., Tsygankov P. А. 2003. Teoriya mezhdunarodnykh otnosheniy v Rossii: otchego ne speshat poyavlyat'sya shkoly? [Theory of International Relations in Russia: Why Aren’t Schools in a Hurry to Appear?]. International Trends. 1(3). P. 104–116.
55. Tsygankov A.P., Tsygankov P.A. 2022. Globalnost i samobytnost v teorii mezhdunarodnykh otnosheniy [Globalism and Uniqueness in International Relations Theory]. Vestnik RUDN. International Relations. 22(1). P. 7–16.
56. Tsygankov P. A. 2003. Sistemnyi podkhod v analize mezhdunarodnykh situatsii [System Approach in the Analysis of International Situations]. International Trends. 1.(1). P. 132–134. (In Russian)
57. Tsygankov P. A. 2013. Sistemnyi podkhod v teorii mezhdunarodnykh otnoshenii [System Approach in the Theory of International Relations]. Moscow University Bulletin. Series 12. Political Science. 5. P. 3–25. (In Russian)
58. Tsymburskiy V.L. 2007. Ostrov Rossiya [The Island Russia]. Moscow: ROSSPEN. 543 p. (In Russian)
59. Varga E.S. 1923. Krizis mirovogo kapitalisticheskogo khozyaystva [The Crisis of the World Capitalist Economy]. Petrograd: Gosudarstvennoe izdatelstvo. 126 p. (In Russian)
60. Varga E.S. 1946. Izmeneniya v ekonomike kapitalizma v itoge Vtoroy mirovoy voyny [Changes in the Capitalist Economy as a Result of World War II]. Moscow: OGIZ. 320 p. (In Russian)
61. Varga E.S. 1953. Osnovnye voprosy ekonomiki i politiki imperializma (posle Vtoroy mirovoy voyny) [Main Issues of the Economy and Politics of Imperialism (After World War II)]. Moscow: Politizdat. 576 p. (In Russian)
62. Varga E.S. 1957. Osnovnye voprosy ekonomiki i politiki imperializma (posle Vtoroy mirovoy voyny). 2-e izd. [Main Issues of the Economy and Politics of Imperialism (After World War II), 2nd ed.]. Moscow: Politizdat. 548 p. (In Russian)
63. Varga E.S. 1974. Nachalo obshchego krizisa kapitalizma. Izbrannye proizvedeniya [The Beginning of the General Crisis of Capitalism. Selected Works]. Moscow: Nauka. 446 p. (In Russian)
Review
For citations:
Istomin I.A. Systems approach in the Soviet IR Theory: The Sources and Consequences of a Tacit Scientific Revolution. MGIMO Review of International Relations. 2025;18(1):66-99. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.24833/2071-8160-2025-1-100-66-99
Views:
970
Email this article 