Narratives of the Traumatic Past in the Japanese Historical Memory Museums
https://doi.org/10.24833/2071-8160-2025-3-102-115-133
Abstract
The article explores narratives of traumatic historical events presented in Japanese museums of historical memory, with a particular focus on representations related to Japan's involvement in World War II and its colonial past. Utilizing theoretical frameworks of historical memory as a form of social construction and symbolic politics, the authors analyze museum exhibitions as tools for disseminating specific historical narratives, which significantly influence contemporary public discourse and collective identity in Japan. The research is structured around an analysis of four representative case studies: the Yushukan Museum, the Memorial Museum for Soldiers, Detainees in Siberia, and Postwar Repatriates, the Northern Territories Museum, and the Women's Active Museum on War and Peace. Each museum reflects distinct mnemonic traditions—radical conservative, moderate conservative, and progressive—and employs varied strategies and methodologies to convey their particular historical narratives. Through these case studies, the article identifies five ideal-typical memory models as defined by Matteo Dian: glorification of the past, self-victimization, historical amnesia, acknowledgment of guilt, and genuine repentance. The analysis demonstrates how each museum utilizes different representational mechanisms—such as textual information, visual displays, personal narratives, and emotional appeals—to foster specific interpretations of history. The authors argue that the diversity of historical narratives within Japanese memory museums results from competing mnemonic traditions and actors within society, including political parties, government institutions, religious organizations, and civic groups. The coexistence of state-supported and private museums further reinforces narrative pluralism. This pluralism reflects ongoing societal debates around Japan's wartime actions and continues to shape national identity, historical consciousness, and international relations.
Supporting agencies: This research was supported by the Russian Science Foundation under grant No. 23-18-00109
About the Authors
D. V. Streltsov
MGIMO University
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Dmitry V. Streltsov – Professor, Head of the Department of Afro-Asian Studies; Leading Research Fellow at the Institute of China and Contemporary Asia, Russian Academy of Sciences (RAS)
76, Prospekt Vernadskogo, 119454, Moscow, Russia
J. P. Fokin
MGIMO University
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Iaroslav P. Fokin – Graduate student
76, Prospekt Vernadskogo, 119454, Moscow, Russia
References
1. Akaha T. 2008. The Nationalist Discourse in Contemporary Japan: The Role of China and Korea in the Last Decade. Pacific Focus. 23 (2). P. 156-188. DOI: 10.1111/j.1976-5118.2008.00009.x
2. Allen M., Sakamoto R. 2013. War and Peace: War Memories and Museums in Japan. History Compass. 11 (12). P. 1047-1058. DOI: 10.1111/hic3.12108
3. Barrand J. 1969. Museums and the Teaching of History. Teaching History. 1(2). P. 65–71.
4. Dian M. 2017. Contested Memories in Chinese and Japanese Foreign Policy. Oxford: Elsevier. 304 p.
5. Gluck C. 1990. The idea of Showa. Daedalus. 119(3). P. 1–26.
6. Hook G.D. 2003. Militarisation and demilitarisation in contemporary Japan. London: Routledge.
7. Iwasaki M., Richter S. 2008. The Topology of Post-1990s Historical Revisionism. Positions.
8. Asia Critique. 16 (3). P. 507-538. DOI: 10.1215/10679847-2008-012
9. Nishino R. 2007. The Women’s Active Museum On War And Peace: Its Role In Public Education. Asia-Pacific Journal. 5 (12). P. 1-7.
10. Poulot D. 2011. Preface. Uses of the Past – Historical Narratives and the Museum. In: Poulot D., F. Bodenstei, J.M.L. Guira (eds). Great Narratives of the Past. Traditions and Revisions in National Museums. Conference proceedings from EuNaMus. European National Museums: Identity Politics, the Uses of the Past and the European Citizen. Paris, 29 June – 1 July & 25-26 November 2011. Linköping University Electronic Press. http://www.ep.liu.se/ecp_home/index.en.aspx?issue=078
11. Savenije G.M., de Bruijn P. 2017. Historical empathy in a museum: uniting contextualisation and emotional engagement. International Journal of Heritage Studies. 23(9). P. 832-845. DOI: 10.1080/13527258.2017.1339108
12. Seaton P. 2015. The Nationalist Assault on Japan’s Local Peace Museums: The Conversion of Peace Osaka. Asia-Pacific Journal. 13 (30). No. 3. P. 1-20.
13. Seraphim, F. 2007. Relocating War Memory as the century's end. In S. M. Jager & R. Mitter (Eds.). Ruptured Histories: war, memory, and the post-Cold War in Asia. Cambridge: Harvard University Press. P. 14-46.
14. Takenaka A. 2014. Reactionary Nationalism and Museum Controversies: The Case of “Peace
15. Osaka”. The Public Historian. 36 (2). P. 75-98. DOI: 10.1525/tph.2014.36.2.75
16. Watson S. 2015. Emotions in the History Museum. In The International Handbooks of Museum Studies (eds S. Macdonald and H. Rees Leahy). P. 283-301. DOI: 10.1002/9781118829059. wbihms992
17. Yoshida T. 2007. Revising the Past, Complicating the Future: The Yushukan War Museum in Modern Japanese History. Asia-Pacific Journal. 5(12). P. 1–8.
18. Chugrov S.V. 2020. Pereosmysleniye itogov Vtoroy mirovoy voyny v sovremennoy Yaponii [Rethinking the Results of World War II in Contemporary Japan]. Polis. Political Studies. 5. P. 22-45. DOI: 10.17976/jpps/2020.05.03 (in Russian).
19. Georgiev Y.V. (ed.) Kurily – ostrova v okeane problem. [Kuriles – islands in an ocean of problems]. Moscow: Rosspen. (in Russian).
20. Ivanova O.V. 2022. Kommemorativnye praktiki muzeev pamjati: opyt Muzeja istorii GULAGa [Commemorative practices of Memory Museums: the experience of the Gulag History Museum]. Historia provinciae – the journal of regional history. 6(4). P. 1366–1418. DOI: 10.23859/25878344-2022-6-4-7 (in Russian).
21. Kulneva P.V. 2020. Yaponskaya agressiya v Kitaye i chuvstvo viny [Japanese aggression in China and the feeling of guilt]. Japanese Studies in Russia. 4. P. 21–39. (In Russian). DOI: 10.24411/25002872-2020-10026 (in Russian).
22. Kuzin A.T. 2010. Problemy poslevoennoj repatriacii japonskogo i korejskogo naselenija Sahalina [The problems of the post-war repatriation of the Japanese and Korean population of Sakhalin]. Russia and the Asia-Pacific region. 2(68). P.76-83. (In Russian).
23. Malinova O.Ju. 2018. Politika pamjati kak oblastʹ simvoličeskoj politiki. [Memory policy as an area of symbolic policy]. In: A.I. Miller, D.V. Efremenko (ed.). Metodologičeskie voprosy izučenija politiki pamjati [Methodological issues of studying memory policy]. Moscow-St. Petersburg: Nestor- Istorija. P. 27-53 (in Russian).
24. Mahotina E.I. 2018. Narrativy muzealizacii, politika vospominanija, pamjatʹ kak šou: Novye napravlenija memory studies v Germanii. [Narratives of musealization, politics of memory, memory as a show: New directions of memory studies in Germany]. In: A. I. Miller, D. V. Efremenko (ed.). Metodologičeskie voprosy izučenija politiki pamjati [Methodological issues of studying memory policy]. Moscow-St. Petersburg: Nestor- Istorija. P. 57-92 (in Russian).
25. Nelidov V.V. 2022. Istoričeskaja pamjatʹ vo vnešnepolitičeskom diskurse Japonii [Historical memory in the foreign policy discourse of Japan]. In: V: D.V.Streltsov (ed.). Problemy istoričeskogo prošlogo v otnošenijah Japonii so stranami-sosedjami [Problems of the historical past in Japan's relations with neighboring countries]. Moscow: Aspekt Press. P. 29-52. (in Russian).
26. Streltsov D.V. 2014. Problemy istoričeskogo prošlogo v poslevoennyh otnošenijah Japonii so stranami Vostočnoj Azii. [Problems of the historical past in Japan's post-war relations with East Asian countries]. Yearbook Japan 2014. 43. P. 7-27. (in Russian).
27. Streltsov D. V. 2020. «Diplomatiya izvineniy» vo vneshney politike poslevoyennoy Yaponii. [“The Diplomacy of Apologies” in the Foreign Policy of Postwar Japan]. Yearbook Japan 2020. 49. P. 29-61. DOI: 10.24411/2687-1432-2020-10002 (in Russian).
28. Streltsov D.V. (ed.). 2022. Problemy istoričeskogo prošlogo v otnošenijah Japonii so stranamisosedjami [Problems of the historical past in Japan's relations with neighboring countries]. Moscow: Aspekt Press. 352 p. (in Russian).
29. Shlyakhtina L.M. 2011. Sovremennyj muzej: idei i realii [The Modern Museum: ideas and realities]. Voprosy muzeologii. 2(4). P. 14-19. (in Russian).
Review
For citations:
Streltsov D.V., Fokin J.P. Narratives of the Traumatic Past in the Japanese Historical Memory Museums. MGIMO Review of International Relations. 2025;18(3):115-133. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.24833/2071-8160-2025-3-102-115-133
Views:
22
Email this article 