Deja vu: Medieval Motifs in Modern Arab Political Life
https://doi.org/10.24833/2071-8160-2019-4-67-38-53
Abstract
The article analyzes specific elements of the Arab societies’ political life which distinguish it from political relations in the Western nation-states. Admitting the existence of a large number of such kind of elements, the authors focus only on three of them which are related to the sources of power and its distribution. Emphasizing that these elements are deeply rooted into the Arab-Muslim political tradition, so that they have tended to be present throughout the whole Islamic period of the region, the authors find out that each of them has its own medieval countertype. Thus, the article addresses the dichotomy of the supreme power of caliphs and sultans, formed in the IX – XI centuries and manifested today both in Jihadist organizations (i.e. ISIS, Al-Qaeda) and in the political strategies of moderate Islamist movements, such as Tunisian party Al-Nahda. The second example is the urban militias, which are correlated with the medieval phenomenon of «young hero» or «chivalry» communities – fityan. The fityan communities have seven specific traits, which not only are characteristic of the militias, but also demonstrate fundamental difference between the militias and urban criminal groups. Major attention is paid to Libyan militias, which are studied on the materials of field research conducted by one of the authors. Finally, the third element discussed is the particular role of the army and other security forces in the Arab political systems.
The authors provide three possible interpretations of all the revealed coincidences. According to the first one, they are presented as aberrations of the researcher’s scientific consciousness, which make them look for historical equivalents to contemporary issues. Second interpretation belongs to the tradition of «the new medievalism». According to it, the described phenomenon is in fact the revival of some medieval practices, caused by the end of the Modernity era. The last interpretation views the analyzed elements as distinctive civilization traits of the Arab world.
About the Authors
V. V. Naumkin
Primakov Institute of World Economy and International Relations, Russian Academy of Sciences
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Vitaly V. Naumkin – Doctor of History, Academician of the Russian Academy of Sciences, Chief Researcher.
23 Profsoyuznaya street, Moscow, 117997.
V. A. Kuznetsov
Primakov Institute of World Economy and International Relations, Russian Academy of Sciences
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Vasily A. Kuznetsov – Candidate of History, Leading Researcher.
23 Profsoyuznaya street, Moscow, 117997.
References
1. Al-Balazuri. 1986. Ansabal-ashraf, msSüleymaniye (Reisülküttap). II(598), fol. 28b.
2. Amri L. 1997. Pour une sociologie des ruptures. La tribu au Maghreb medieval. ‒ Université de Tunis I. Faculté des sciences humaines et sociales, Série Sociologie, No. 2, 310 p.
3. Arab Human Development in the Twenty-First Century. The Primacy of Empowerment. 2014. Ed. by Korany B. Cairo: The American University in Cairo Press.
4. Arab Society. Class, Gender, Power, and Development. 2006. Ed. by Hopkins N.S., Ibrahim S.E. Third edition. Cairo: American University in Cairo Press. 416 p.
5. At-Tabari. 1995. Ta’rih at-Tabari. Bejrut. T. 4.
6. Cahen Cl. 1991. Futuwwa. The Encyclopaedia of Islam. Vol. II. Leiden: E.J. Brill.
7. Crone P. 1980. Slaves on Horses: The Evolution of the Islamic Polity. Cambridge. 302 p.
8. Crone P. 1986. God’s Caliph: Religious Authority in First Centuries of Islam. Cambridge. 157 p.
9. Lacher W., Alaa al-Idrissi. 2018. Capital of Militias. Tripoli’s Armed Groups Capture the Libyan State. SANA Briefing Paper, June 2018. 20 p.
10. Lassner J. 1980. The Shaping of ‘Abbasid Rule. New Jersey: Princeton University Press. 348 p.
11. Lewis Cl.B. 1968. The Regnal Titles of the First Abbasid Caliphs. Dr. Zakir Husain Presentation Volume. New Delhi.
12. Mavardi, Al-Hasan ‘Ali bin Muhammad bin Habib al-Basri al-Bagdadi. 1996. Al-Ahkam as-sultanija. Kair – Damask – Amman: Al-maktab al-islamij. Ouannes M. 2009. Militaires, élites et modernization dans la Libye contemporaine. Paris: L’Harmattan.
13. Nassar N. 2003. Mafhum al-umma bajna-d-din va-t-ta’rih. Bejrut.
14. Robinson Ch.F. 2005. ‘Abd al-Malik. Oxford: Oneworld.
15. Taeschner Fr. 1986. ‘Ayyar. – The Encyclopaedia of Islam. Vol. I, Leiden: E.J. Brill.
16. Tor D.G. 2007. Violent Order. Religious Warfare, Chivalry and the ‘Ayyar Phenomenon in the Medieval Islamiс World. Wurzburg: Ergon Verlag Wurzburg in Kommission.
17. Triki F. 1991. L’esprit historien dans la civilisation arabe et islamique. Tunis: Maison Tunisienne de l’Edition – Faculté des Sciences Humaines et Sociales de Tunis. 400 p.
18. Al-Mas‘udi. 2002. Zolotye kopi i rossypi samocvetov [Gold Mines and Placers of Gems]. Moscow: Natalis. 799 p. (In Russian)
19. Galeotti M. 2019. Vory. Istoriya organizovannoj prestupnosti v Rossii [Robbers. Russia’s Super Mafia]. Moscow, Individuum. 448 p. (In Russian)
20. Gasymov K. 2015. Razlad v stane dzhihadistov: ideologicheskaya bor'ba Al'-Kaidy s organizaciej «Islamskoe gosudarstvo» [Discord in the Jihadists Camp: Al-Qaeda’s Ideological Battle with the Islamic State]. Indeks bezopasnosti. No. 3. P. 61-82. (In Russian)
21. Ignatenko A.A. 1989. V poiskah schast'ya. Obshchestvenno-politicheskie vozzreniya araboislamskih filosofov srednevekov'ya [In search of Happiness. Socio-Political Views of the Arab-Islamic Philosophers of the Middle Ages]. Moscow: Mysl'. 254 p. (In Russian)
22. Mirskij G.I. 1989. Rol' armii v politicheskoj zhizni stran «Tret'ego mira» [The Role of the Army in the Sociopolitical Development of Asian and African Countries]. Moscow: Nauka. 198 p. (In Russian)
23. Naumkin V.V. 2014. Civilizacii i krizis nacij-gosudarstv [Civilizations and the Crisis of Nation-States]. Rossiya v global'noj politike. No. 1. P. 41-59. (In Russian)
24. Naumkin V.V., Baranovskij V.G. and oth. 2018. Blizhnij Vostok v menyayushchemsya global'nom kontekste [The Middle East in a Changing Global Context]. Moscow: IV RAN Publ. 556 p. (In Russian)
25. Sapronova M.A. 2012. Postrevolyucionnye konstitucii i instituty vlasti arabskih stran (na primere Egipta, Marokko i Tunisa) [Post-Revolutionary Constitutions and Institutions of Power of the Arab Countries (the Examples of Egypt, Morocco and Tunisia)]. Politicheskaya nauka. No. 3. Р. 179-198. (In Russian)
26. Vajs M., Hasan H. 2016. Islamskoe gosudarstvo. Armiya terror [ISIS: Inside the Army of Terror]. Moscow: Al'pina non-fikshn. 346 p, (In Russian)
27. Zvyagel'skaya I.D. 2017. Suverenitet i gosudarstvennost' na Blizhnem Vostoke – nevynosimaya hrupkost' bytiya [Sovereignty and Statehood in the Middle East – Intolerable Fragility of Life]. Kontury global'nyh transformacij: politika, ekonomika, pravo. No. 2. P. 97-109. (In Russian) DOI: 10.23932/2542-0240-2017-10-2-97-109
28. Zvyagel'skaya I.D. 2018. Blizhnij Vostok i Central'naya Aziya: global'nye trendy v regional'nom ispolnenii [Middle East and Central Asia: Global Trends in Regional Performance]. Moscow: Aspekt Press. 224 p. (In Russian)
29. Zvyagel'skaya I.D. 2019. Simvoly i cennosti v mezhdunarodnyh otnosheniyah na Blizhnem Vostoke [Symbols and Values in International Relations in The Middle East]. Polis. Politicheskie issledovaniya. No. 1. P. 105-123. (In Russian) DOI: 10.17976/jpps/2019.01.08
30. Zvyagel'skaya I.D., Kuznetsov V.A. 2017. Gosudarstvennost' na Blizhnem Vostoke. Budushchee nachalos' vchera [Sovereignty and Statehood in The Middle East: The Future which Started Yesterday]. Mezhdunarodnye process. No. 4. P. 6-19. (In Russian)
Review
For citations:
Naumkin V.V., Kuznetsov V.A. Deja vu: Medieval Motifs in Modern Arab Political Life. MGIMO Review of International Relations. 2019;12(4):38-53. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.24833/2071-8160-2019-4-67-38-53
Views:
1431
Email this article 