Great Northern War and Church reform of Peter the Great
https://doi.org/10.24833/2071-8160-2021-6-81-153-171
Abstract
The article presents historical research on the Church reform of Peter I, considering the Great Northern War (1700–1721) as one of the crucial transformational factors in church-state relations in Russia. The article introduces descriptive books of patriarchal estates in 17 counties of Russia. They were created during the audit of Church and monastic property in line with the decree of January 31, 1701. It considers features of the form and content of these documents and previously known descriptions of bishops' houses and monasteries, which were carried out according to the mandated memorials of the Monastic Order in 1701-1705. The article claims that the secularization of the patriarch's landholdings, in contrast to other church holdings, was complete and final already at the beginning of the 18th century. In this regard, there is an obvious need to reject historical parallels between the events of the early 18th century and the "monastic secularization" of 1764.
Comparing the Alexei Kurbatov’s proposals to Peter I in a letter dated October 25, 1700, with the content of the personal decrees of January 24 and 31, 1701 on the restoration of the Monastic Order allows us to hypothesize that the defeat at Narva and preparation for the meeting with the Elector Augustus II that would result in the signing of the Biržai pact, significantly adjusted the plans of the Church reform. The novelty of the January decrees that presumably started the reform (in the then-common European sense of the concept) was the inclusion of the patriarch's estates in the list of the Church's possessions subject to the control of the state in the future.
I conclude that the secularization of church-monastic possessions and property that followed at the beginning of the Great Northern War not only contradicted the centuries-old historical practice but was at that time organizationally overwhelming for the state, which was able to solve the problem of managing the escheat patriarchal lands but did not yet have the appropriate staffing and logistics capacities for control over all possessions of the Church.
About the Author
N. V. Sokolova
Institute of Slavic Studies of the Russian Academy of Sciences
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Natalia V. Sokolova, Candidate of Historical Sciences, Senior Researcher Fellow
119334, build. 32-А, Leninsky Prospect, Moscow, Russia
References
1. Bagger Kh. 1985. Reformy Petra Velikogo: Obzor issledovanii [Reforms of Peter the Great. Literature Review]. Moscow: Progress. 203 p. (In Russian).
2. Bashnin N.V., Cherkasova M.S. 2021. Kak nachinalas' tserkovnaia reforma Petra I? (po materialam severnorusskikh eparkhii 1690-1700-kh gg.) [How did the Church Reform of Peter I begin? (based on the materials of the Northern Russian Dioceses of the 1690s–1700s)]. Canadian-American Slavic Studies. 55 (1). P. 24-50. DOI 10.30965/22102396-05501002 (In Russian).
3. Bulygin I.A. 1977. Monastyrskie krest'iane Rossii v pervoi chetverti XVIII v. [Monastic peasants of Russia in the first quarter of the 18th Century]. Moscow: Nauka. 327 p. (In Russian).
4. Bulygin I.A. 1974. Tserkovnaia reforma Petra I [Church Reform of Peter I]. Voprosy istorii. 5. P. 79-83. (In Russian).
5. Discussion on the reports of P.Yu. Uvarov, S.E. Fedorov and L.A. Pimenova [Diskussiya po dokladam P.Yu.Uvarova, S.Ye. Fyodorova i L.A. Pimenovoy]. Fenomen reform na zapade i vostoke Evropy v nachale Novogo vremeni (XVI-XVIII vv.). Sbornik statei. [The Phenomenon of Reforms in the West and east of Europe at the Beginning of the Modern period (16th-18th Centuries). A collection of articles]. Ed. by Krom M.M., Pimenova L.A. 2013. St. Petersburg: Izdatel'stvo Evropeiskogo universiteta. P. 69-76. (In Russian).
6. Verkhovskoi P.V. 1916. Uchrezhdenie dukhovnoi kollegii i Dukhovnyi reglament. K voprosu ob otnoshenii tserkvi i gosudarstva v Rossii. Issledovaniia v oblasti istorii russkogo tserkovnogo prava [Establishment of the Spiritual College and the Spiritual Regulation. On the Issue of the Relationship between Church and State in Russia. Research in the History of Russian Ecclesiastical law]. Rostov-na-Donu: Novoe vremia. Vol. 1. [2], XXVI, CLXXVIII, 686 p. (In Russian).
7. Gorchakov M.I. 1868. Monastyrskii prikaz (1649-1725 g.): Opyt istorichesko-iuridicheskogo issledovaniia [Monastic Prikaz (1649-1725): an Attempt at a Historical and Legal Research]. St. Petersburg: tip. A. Transhelia. 159 p. (In Russian).
8. Gorchakov M.I. 1871. O zemel'nykh vladeniiakh vserossiiskikh mitropolitov, patriarkhov i Sv. sinoda. (988-1738 gg.): Iz opytov issledovaniia v istorii russkogo prava [On the Land Holdings of the All-Russian Metropolitans, Patriarchs and the Holy Synod. (988-1738): From attempts at research in the history of Russian law]. St. Petersburg: tip. A. Transhelia. 558, 252 p. (In Russian).
9. Krom M.M., Pimenova L.A. Phenomen reform v Evrope rannego novogo vremeni [The Phenomenon of Reforms in Early Modern Europe]. Fenomen reform na zapade i vostoke Evropy v nachale Novogo vremeni (XVI-XVIII vv.). Sbornik statei. [The Phenomenon of Reforms in the West and east of Europe at the Beginning of the Modern period (16th-18th Centuries). A collection of articles]. Ed. by Krom M.M., Pimenova L.A. 2013. St. Petersburg: Izdatel'stvo Evropeiskogo universiteta. P. 7-16. (In Russian).
10. Nikol'skii N.M. 1912. Tserkovnaia reforma Petra [Church Reform of Peter I]. Tri veka: Rossiia ot smuty do nashego vremeni. Istoricheskii sbornik [Three Centuries: Russia from the Time of Troubles to today. Historical digest]. Ed. by V.V. Kallash. Vol. 3. Moscow: T-vo I.D. Sytina. P. 180-197. (In Russian).
11. Pavlenko P.N. 2006. Istoriia Petra Velikogo [The History of Peter the Great]. Moscow: Veche. 570 p. (In Russian).
12. Pimenova L.A. 2013. Reformy i reformatory vo Frantsii v vek Prosveshcheniia [Reforms and Reformers in France in the Age of Enlightenment]. Fenomen reform na zapade i vostoke Evropy v nachale Novogo vremeni (XVI-XVIII vv.). Sbornik statei [The phenomenon of reforms in the west and east of Europe at the beginning of the Modern period (XVI-XVIII centuries). A collection of articles]. Ed. by Krom M.M., Pimenova L.A. St. Petersburg: Izdatel'stvo Evropeiskogo universiteta. P. 59-68. (In Russian).
13. Runkevich S.G. 1900. Istoriia russkoi tserkvi pod upravleniem sviateishego sinoda. T. 1. Uchrezhdenie i pervonachal'noe ustroistvo sviateishego pravitel'stvennogo sinoda (1721-1725 gg.). [History of the Russian Church under the Governance of the Holy Synod. Vol. 1. Establishment and initial structure of the Most Holy Governing Synod (1721-1725)]. St. Petersburg: Tipografiia A.P. Lopukhina. 429 p. (In Russian).
14. Sakharov A.N. 1966. Russkaia derevnia XVII veka. Po materialam patriarshego khoziaistva [Russian Village of the 17th Century. Based on Materials from the Patriarchal Land Holdings]. Moscow: Nauka. 230 p. (In Russian).
15. Sedov P.V. 2013. «Vse de nyne gosudarevo»: traditsii i novatsii v tserkovnoi reforme Petra I [“Everything is Sovereign Now”: Traditions and Innovations in the Church Reform of Peter I]. Fenomen reform na zapade i vostoke Evropy v nachale Novogo vremeni (XVI-XVIII vv.). Sbornik statei. Ed. by Krom M.M., Pimenova L.A. St. Petersburg: Izdatel'stvo Evropeiskogo universiteta. P. 122-142. (In Russian).
16. Slitsan B.G. 1954. Reforma tserkovnogo upravleniia [Church Governance Reform]. Ocherki istorii SSSR. Vol. VII. Period feodalizma. Rossiia v pervoi chetverti XVIII v. Preobrazovaniia Petra I. Moscow: Izdatel'stvo Akademii nauk SSSR. P. 371-379. (In Russian).
17. Smolich I.K. 1999. Russkoe monashestvo. 988-1917 [Russian Monasticism. 988-1917]. Transl. from German by Archpriest Vladislav Tsypin. (Prilozhenie k «Istorii Russkoi Tserkvi»). Moscow: Tserkovno-nauchnyi tsentr «Pravoslavnaia entsiklopediia». 366 p. (In Russian).
18. Sokolova N.V. 2016. Iz istorii boiarskogo zemlevladeniia v Nizhegorodskom uezde v 80-kh gg. XVII v. [From the History of Seigniorial Tenure in Nizhny Novgorod uezd in the 1680s.]. Petersburg historical journal. No4. P. 42-58. (In Russian).
19. Sokolova N.V. 2021. Nizhegorodskaia dvorcovaia derevnia XVI-XVII vekov [Nizhny Novgorod Crown Villages of the 16-17th Century]. Moscow: Aspect Press Ltd. 336 p. (In Russian). DOI: 10.31168/7567-1128-8
20. Sokolova N.V. 2008. Opisanie tserkovnomonastyrskikh vladenii v protsesse sekuliarizatsii nachala XVIII v.: Opyt rekonstruktsii (na materialakh Nizhegorodskogo uezda) [Description of Church and Monastery Lands during Secularization in the Early 18th Century: Experience of Reconstruction on Materials of Nizhny Novgorod Uyezd]. In: Severo-Zapad v agrarnoi istorii Rossii. Mezhvuzovskii tematicheskii sbornik nauchnykh trudov. Kaliningrad. P. 44-60. (In Russian).
21. Shamina I.N. 2017. Perepisnye knigi kolomenskikh Spaso-Preobrazhenskogo, Golutvina, Bobreneva i Brusenskogo monastyrei 1701 g. [Inventory Books of the Kolomna Spaso-Preobrazhensky, Golutvin, Bobrenev and Brusensk Monasteries of 1701]. Vestnik tserkovnoi istorii. 3-4 (47-48). P. 96-226. (In Russian).
22. Shamina I.N. 2021. Prakticheskaia realizaciia pervogo etapa cerkovnoi reformy Petra I. [Practical Implementation of the First Stage of the Church Reform of Peter I (1701-1703)]. Rossiiskaia istoriia. 4. P. 60-73. DOI: 10.31857/S086956870016256-2 (In Russian)
Review
For citations:
Sokolova N.V. Great Northern War and Church reform of Peter the Great. MGIMO Review of International Relations. 2021;14(6):153-171. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.24833/2071-8160-2021-6-81-153-171
Views:
1624
Email this article 