Business or Security? Goals and Decision-Making Inside the French Oil Policy of the 1920s
https://doi.org/10.24833/2071-8160-2022-1-82-38-59
Abstract
The article aims to explore the interplay between economic and strategic reasons, which influenced the oil policy of the French government and business in the 1920s. The author demonstrates the heterogeneity and complexity of this policy the diverse nature of motives and interests behind the different attempts to acquire access to the oil. The French case throws some new light on the role of the “oil factor” in international relations and Great Powers’ politics. The article comprehensively deals with the topics often divided between different fields strategic studies, international political economy, diplomatic history. The author uses French archives to place Paris’ oil policy into the broader context of the French strategy and diplomacy in the first decade after WWI. Additional documents from the British and Russian archives help understand essential aspects of the Anglo-French and FrancoSoviet interactions around the “oil question.” After underlying the new strategic importance of oil, which became evident during WWI, and describing the oil dependence of France from the Anglo-American trusts (“Standard Oil” and “Royal Dutch-Shell”), the author traces the three key aims of the French oil policy. First, to diversify the supplies; second, to acquire control or direct access to the oil sources; and, finally, to consolidate the French business interests with the mediation of the state authorities. French actions in these three directions were interlinked, and they mirrored a specific situation of power and weakness of France after WWI. The article concludes that the strategic and economic reasons were interwoven inside the French oil policy. Though the French authorities perceived the growing strategic importance of oil sharply, they were not prepared to follow the clear étatist economic policy and did not try to make a radical change of the established rules of oil policy both inside the Third Republic and in the relations with “Standard Oil” and “Royal Dutch-Shell.”
Keywords
About the Author
I. E. Magadeev
MGIMO-University
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Iskander E. Magadeev – Candidate of Sciences, Associate Professor, Department of European and American Studies
119454, Moscow, prospekt Vernadskogo, 76
References
1. Baumann F. 2008. Energy Security as Multidimensional Concept. CAP Policy Analysis. 3(1). P. 1–14.
2. Beltran A. 2018. L’industrie pétrolière en France pendant la Première Guerre mondiale: une prise de conscience tardive. L’industrie dans la Grande Guerre. Sous la dir. de P. Fridenson, P. Griset. Paris: Comité pour l’histoire économique et financière de la France. P. 151–159. (In French)
3. Bolech Cecchi D. 2007. The Outlawry of War and the Kellogg-Briand Pact. For Peace in Europe: Institutions and Civil Society between the World Wars. Ed. by M. Petricioli, D. Cherubini. Bruxelles: Peter Lang. P. 141–168.
4. Bussière E. 1982. La France et les affaires pétrolièrs au lendemain de la Première Guerre Mondiale: la politique des groupes financiers à travers celle de la banque de l’Union Parisienne. Histoire, économie et société. 1(2). P. 313–328. (In French)
5. Conlin J. 2015. Drawing the Line: Calouste Gulbenkian and the 1928 Red Line Agreement. The First World War and its Aftermath: the Making of the Modern Middle East. Ed. by T.G. Fraser. London: University of Chicago Press. P. 313–331.
6. Eichengreen B. 2019. Versailles: the Economic Legacy. International Affairs. 95(1). P. 7–24. Earle E.M. 1924. The Turkish Petroleum Company – A Study in Oleaginous Diplomacy. Political Science Quarterly. 39(2).
7. Ferrier R.W. 1984. French Oil Policy, 1917–30: the Interaction between State and Private Interests. Enterprise and history: Essays in honour of Charles Wilson. Ed. by D.C. Coleman, P. Mathias. Cambridge: Cambridge UP. P. 237–262.
8. Ghéciu B. 1921. La politique du pétrole en France. Paris: Université de Paris. (In French)
9. Hogenhuis-Seliverstoff A. 1991. French Plans for the Reconstruction of Russia: A History and Evaluation. Genoa, Rapallo, and European Reconstruction in 1922. Ed. by C. Fink, A. Frohn, J. Heideking. Cambridge: Cambridge UP. P. 131–148.
10. Jeannesson S. 2000. La difficile reprise des relations commerciales entre la France et l’URSS (1921–1928). Histoire, économie et société. 19(3). P. 411–429. (In French)
11. Keeton E.D. 1987. Briand’s Locarno Policy. French Economics, Politics and Diplomacy, 1925–1929. New York: Garland Publishing. 403 p.
12. Kuisel R.F. 1983. Capitalism and the State in Modern France: Renovation and Economic Management in the Twentieth Century. Cambridge: Cambridge UP. 368 p.
13. L’industrie du pétrole. 1934. Revue d’économie politique. Vol. 48.
14. Ledenev S. 2020. Establishing French Control over the Oil Fields of Eastern Galicia, 1918– 1923. Wars and Betweenness: Big Powers in Middle Europe, 1918–1945. Ed. by A. Piahanau, B. Aleksov. New York: Central European UP. P. 103–120.
15. Marguerat Ph. 1987. Banque et investissement industriel. Paribas, le pétrole roumain et la politique française. Genève: Droz. 145 p. (In French)
16. Marguerat Ph. 2004. Les investissements français dans le Bassin danubien durant l’entredeux-guerres: pour une nouvelle interprétation. Revue historique. No629. P. 121–162. (In French)
17. Maurette F. 1926. Le pétrole: étude de géographie économique. Annales de géographie. No193. P. 24.
18. Murat D. 1969. L’intervention de l’État dans le secteur pétrolier en France. Paris: Éditions Techip. 328 p. (In French)
19. Nayberg R. 2006. La politique française du pétrole à l’issue de la Première guerre mondiale: perspectives et solutions. Guerres mondiales et conflits contemporaines. No224. P. 111–133. (In French)
20. Nouschi A. 1976. L’État français et les pétroliers anglo-saxons: la naissance de la Compagnie française des pétroles (1923–1924). Relations internationales. No7. P. 241–259. (In French)
21. Nouschi A. 2001. La France et le pétrole de 1924 à nos jours. Paris: Picard. 452 p. (In French) Nowell G.P. 1994. Mercantile States and the World Oil Cartel, 1900–1939. Ithaca: Cornell UP. 326 p.
22. Pelletier F. 2018. Pétrole et enjeux politiques en France: La naissance d’un secteur stratégique. Vingtième Siècle. No140. P. 123–136. (In French)
23. Pineau L. 1925. La politique française du pétrole et des combustibles liquides. Bulletin Quotidien de la Société d’études et d’informations économiques. 18 avril 1925. No87. P. 1–31. (In French)
24. Régime d’importation du pétrole. 1928. Annales de l’Office national des comustibles liquides. 3(2). P. 245–247.
25. Salut S. 2006. Politique nationale du pétrole, sociétés nationales et «pétrole franc». Revue historique. No638. P. 355–388. (In French)
26. Sassi M. 2004a. Evolution of the Structure of the French Oil Economy between the Wars: Toward a French Holding Company. Business and Economic History On-Line. Vol. 2. P. 1–23.
27. Sassi M. 2004b. Le rôle du technocrate: Ernest Mercier et la mise en place d’une industrie française entre les deux guerres [Electronic ressource]. Bulletin de l’IHTP. No84. (In French). URL: https://ihtp2004-siteihtp2004.ihtp.cnrs.fr/spip.php?article311&lang=fr (accessed 13.02.2022)
28. Scazzieri L. 2015. Britain, France and Mesopotamian Oil, 1916–1920. Diplomacy & Statecraft. 26(1). P. 25–45.
29. Smith M.S. 2005. The Emergence of Modern Business Enterprise in France, 1800–1930. Cambridge (Massachusetts): Harvard UP. 575 p.
30. Soutou G.-H. 1976. L’impérialisme du pauvre: la politique économique du gouvernement français en Europe centrale et orientale de 1918 à 1929. Relations internationales. No7. P. 219– 239. (In French)
31. Stivers W. 1983. A Note on the Red Line Agreement. Diplomatic History. 7(1). P. 23–34. Sutton A.C. 1970. Western Technology and Soviet Economic Development, 1917 to 1930.
32. 2nd ed. Stanford: Hoover Institution on War, Revolution and Peace. 381 p.
33. Toprani A. 2019. Oil and the Great Powers: Britain and Germany, 1914 to 1945. Oxford: Oxford UP. 336 p.
34. Borisov Ju.V. 1964. Sovetsko-francuzskie otnoshenija (1924–1945 gg.) [Soviet-French Relations (1924–1945)]. Moscow: Mezhdunarodnye otnoshenija Publ. 551 p. (In Russian)
35. Boronov R. 1977. Neft’ i politika SShA na Blizhnem i Srednem Vostoke [Oil and the US Policy in the Near and Middle East]. Moscow: Nauka Publ. 271 p. (In Russian)
36. Ergin D. 2006. Garantirovat’ jenergeticheskuju bezopasnost’ [To Guarantee the Energy Security] [Electronic ressource]. Rossija v global’noj politike. No1. (In Russian) URL: http://www. globalaffairs.ru/number/n_6320 (accessed 13.02.2022).
37. Ergin D. 2011. Dobycha: Vsemirnaja istorija bor’by za neft’, den’gi i vlast’ [The Prize: The Epic Quest for Oil, Money, and Power]. Moscow: «Al’pina Publ.». 944 p. (In Russian)
38. Fomin A.M. 2010. Vojna s prodolzheniem. Velikobritanija i Francija v bor'be za «Osmanskoe nasledstvo». 1918–1923 [War Continues. Great Britain and France Struggling for the “Ottoman Heritage”. 1918–1923]. Moscow: Russkij fond sodejstvija obrazovaniju i nauke. 449 p. (In Russian)
39. Sobolev E.V. 2007. Anglo-amerikanskoe sopernichestvo za neft’ Arabskih jemiratov Persidskogo zaliva (1923–1938 gg.) [Anglo-American Struggle for the Oil of Arabian Emirates in the Persian Gulf (1923–1938)]. Ph.D. Dissertation. Ekaterinburg: [s.l.]. 186 p. (In Russian)
40. Tardieu A. 1943. Mir [The World]. Moscow: Gospolitizdat. (In Russian)
41. Tilli Ch. 2009. Prinuzhdenie, kapital i evropejskie gosudarstva. 990–1992 gg. [Coercion, Capital, and European States, AD 990–1990]. Moscow: Izdatel’skij dom «Territorija budushhego». 360 p. (In Russian)
42. Valiahmetova G.N. 2006. Anglo-francuzskoe sopernichestvo na Blizhnem Vostoke i stroitel’stvo irakskogo nefteprovoda (1928–1934) [Anglo-French Struggle in the Near East and the Construction of the Irak Pipeline (1928–1934)]. Izvestija Ural’skogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Ser. 2. No47. P. 305–321. (In Russian)
43. Valiahmetova G.N. 2009. Irakskaja neft’ v mezhdunarodnoj politike na Blizhnem Vostoke (1928–1941 gody) [Irak Oil in the International Policy in the Near East (1928–1941)]. Novaja i novejshaja istorija. No6. P. 32–50. (In Russian)
44. Valiahmetova G.N. 2010. Irakskaja neft’ v politike velikih derzhav na Blizhnem Vostoke (1932–1941 gg.) [Irak Oil in the Great Powers’ Politics in the Near East (1932–1941)]. Moscow: RAS Institute of the East. 444 p. (In Russian)
Review
For citations:
Magadeev I.E. Business or Security? Goals and Decision-Making Inside the French Oil Policy of the 1920s. MGIMO Review of International Relations. 2022;15(1):38-59. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.24833/2071-8160-2022-1-82-38-59
Views:
894
Email this article 