Nation vs. People: The Axiology of Group Identity
https://doi.org/10.24833/2071-8160-2022-4-85-151-166
Abstract
The article takes a political philosophical perspective in a conceptual analysis of the nation, focusing on its axiological foundations in the political theories of modernity and postmodernity. It reviews the political philosophy arguments explaining conditions and reasons for individual ethnic groups to become nations. The author emphasizes the role of religion in this process as the main factor in forming national values and identity beyond tribal ties. Despite its importance religion is often dismissed in the research literature on nationalism and nation-building.
To stress the importance of collective solidarity for sustaining a national identity, the author juxtaposes the idea of the nation understood as a collective of individuals living in a nationstate united by common values to the idea of the people understood as a collective of individuals living in a nation-state driven solely by their egoistic interests. From this perspective the people render institutions of the national state dysfunctional because of their disrespect for the common values, while the nation strengthens state institutions, making its nationstate resilient to the current global problems.
About the Author
H. T. Sardaryan
MGIMO-University
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Henry T. Sardaryan – Doctor of Political Science, Dean of the Faculty of Management and Politics
76 Vernadsky Avenue, Moscow, 19454
References
1. Anderson B. 1991. Imagined Communities: Reflections on the Origins and Spread of Nationalism. London: Verso.
2. Baudrillard J. 2016. The Consumer Society. Myths and Structures. SAGE Publications. Brubaker R. 2011. Religion and nationalism: four approaches. Nations and Nationalism. 18(1). P. 1–19.
3. Foucault M. 2008. The History of Sexuality. The Will to Knowledge. Vol. 1. Penguin.
4. Foucault M. 2011. Key Concepts. Acumen.
5. Fukuyama F. 2019. Dentity. The Demand for Dignity and the Politics of Resentment. Picador.
6. Hazony Y. 2018. The Virtue of Nationalism. Basic Books.
7. Locke J. 2018. Second Treatise of Government. Create Space Independent Publishing Platform.
8. Montesquieu. 2019. The Spirit of Laws. Creative Media Partners, LLC.
9. Rorty R. 1990. Objectivity, Relativism, and Truth. Vol. 1. Cambridge University Press.
10. Toynbee A.J. 1987. A Study of History. Volumes VII-X. Oxford University Press.
11. Wendt A. 1994. Collective Identity Formation and the International State. American Political Science Review. 88(2). Р. 384–396.
12. Wieviorka M. 2012. Le Peuple existe-t-il? Éditions Sciences Humaines. 310 p. (In French).
13. Habermas J. 2001. Vovlecheniye Drugogo. Ocherki politicheskoy teorii. [Involvement of the Other. Essays on Political Theory]. Saint Petersburg: Izdatel'stvo «Nauka». 417 p. (In Russian).
14. Ilyin I.P. 2001. Postmodernizm: slovar' terminov [Postmodernism: a Dictionary of Terms]. Moscow: INION RAS – INTRADA. 384 p. (In Russian).
15. Lacan J. 1997. Instanciya bukvy v bessoznatel'nom, ili Sud'ba razuma posle Frejda [The Instance of the Letter in the Unconscious, or the Fate of the Mind after Freud]. Moscow: Logos. 184 p. (In Russian).
16. Lenin V. 1952. O prave nacij na samoopredelenie [On the Right of Nations to Self-Determination]. Moscow: State Publishing House of Political Literature. (In Russian).
17. Marx K., Engels F. 2020. Principy kommunizma. Manifest Kommunisticheskoj partii. [The Principles of Communism. Manifesto of the Communist Party]. Moscow: AST. (In Russian).
18. Miller A.I. 2010. Acquisition Necessary but Quiet Convenient: the Transfer of the Concept of Nation to Russia (Beginning of the 18th – the Middle of the 19th {entury)]. Imperium inter pares: Rol' transferov v istorii Rossiyskoy imperii (1700 – 1917). P. 42-66. (In Russian).
19. Miller A.I. 2015. Istoriya ponyatiya «natsiya» v Rossii (ot Petra I do Krymskoy voyny). [History of the Notion “Nation” in Russia (from Peter I to the Crimean War)]. Vestnik rossiyskoy natsii. No1(39). P. 115-137. (In Russian).
20. Stalin I. 1953. Marksizm i nacional'nyj vopros [Marxism and the National Question]. Moscow: State Publishing House of Political Literature. (In Russian).
21. Tishkov V.A. 2016. Ot etnosa k etnichnosti i posle. [From Ethnos to Ethnicity and Back]. Etnograficheskoye obozreniye. No5. P. 5-22. (In Russian).
22. Tishkov V.A. 2021. Otkuda i kuda prishla rossiyskaya etnologiya: personal'nyy vzglyad v global'noy perspective. [Where did Russian Ethnology Come to: Personal View in Global Perspective]. Vestnik Rossiyskoy Akademii Nauk. 91(3). P. 215-231. (In Russian).
Review
For citations:
Sardaryan H.T. Nation vs. People: The Axiology of Group Identity. MGIMO Review of International Relations. 2022;15(4):151-166. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.24833/2071-8160-2022-4-85-151-166
Views:
738
Email this article 