The Epoch and Personality of Peter the Great in Nikolay Charykov’s Research
https://doi.org/10.24833/2071-8160-2022-5-86-7-26
Abstract
The article reviews the academic contribution of Russian historian and diplomat Nikolay Charykov (1855-1930) to our understanding of the reforms by Peter the Great. In his research, Nikolay Charykov argues that the reforms did not result in a radical break with previous Russia's historical path. He stresses that the cultivation of scientific knowledge and labor skills necessary for modernization started in Russia long before Peter the Great because Russia was part of a European system even before Peter the Great. For example, the author points to Ivan III's marriage to Zoe Palaiologina (Sophia Palaiologina); the employment of captive Livonians by Ivan IV; sending Russian youth to study at Western European universities; Boris Godunov's plans to form a European league of Christian sovereigns. Nikolay Charykov focuses in his studies on the reign of Tsar Alexei Mikhailovich, pointing to his plans to increase the involvement of Westerners in various spheres of life in Russia. Moreover, Nikolay Charykov shows that the personality of the future Emperor was formed under the influence of Russia's increasing interaction with European countries. He concludes that the development of Russia before Peter led to Peter's reforms. He saw the struggle between Sophia and Peter as an interpersonal struggle for power, which in no way violated the primary trend of Russia's development. Peter's reforms became a logical and natural consequence of the previous processes. The merit of Peter was that he successfully continued the previously started transformations by adding to them his character and thinking, which led to the birth of the Russian Empire.
About the Author
O. A. Chernov
Samara State Social and Pedagogical University
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Oleg A. Chernov – Doctor of Historical Sciences, Associate Professor, Professor of the Depart- ment of National History and Archaeology
Gorky, 65/67, 443099, Samara, Russian Federation
References
1. Bushkovitch P. 2001. Peter the Great the Struggle for Power, 1671–1725. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 187 p.
2. Fedosov D. 2000. Scotland and Russia: A Boundless Bond. Russia and the Wider World in Historical Perspective. London–New York. P. 67-84.
3. Jensen C.R. 2009. Musical Cultures in Seventeenth-Century Russia. Bloomington. 376 p.
4. Krasic P. 1986. Stjepan Gradić prema Rusiji Križaniceva doba. Zbornik Odsjeka za povijesne znanosti Zavoda za povijesne i društvene znanosti Hrvatske akademije znanosti i umjetnosti. Vol. 14. Lipanj. P. 257-270. (In Croatian)
5. Oresko R. 1997. The House the Savoj in Search for a Royal Crown in the 17th Century.
6. Royal and republican sovereignty in early modern Europe: essays in memory of Ragnhild Hat-ton. New York P. 272-350.
7. Tcharykow N.V. 1904. Le chevalier Raphael Barberini chez le tsar Jean le Terrible. Paris.
8. Tcharykow N.V. 1930. The Roman Question, Leo XIII, and signor Mussolini. The Contemporary Review. Vol. CXXXVII (137). P. 338.
9. Tcharykow N.V. 1931. Glimpses of High Politics. London. P. 42.
10. Charykov N.V. 1876. Posol'stvo v Angliyu dvoryanina Grigoriya Mikulina v 1600 i 1601 gg. [The Embassy to England of the Nobleman Grigory Mikulin in 1600 and 1601]. Saint Petersburg. (In Russian)
11. Charykov N.V. 1883. Kosmografiya. 1670. [Cosmography. 1670]. Saint Petersburg. (In Russian)
12. Charykov N.V. 1900. Pavel Menezij. Ego diplomaticheskaya i voennaya sluzhba pri Moskovskom dvore i predpolagaemoe nastavnichestvo pri Petre Velikom [Paul Menezius. His Diplomatic and Military Service at the Moscow Court and his Supposed Mentorship under Peter the Great]. Istoricheskij vestnik. No11–12. P. 510–532, 935–968. (In Russian)
13. Charykov N.V. 1912. Ob ital'yanskoj freske, izobrazhayushchej Ioanna III i Sof'yu Paleolog [About the Italian Fresco Depicting John III and Sophia Palaiologos]. Saint Petersburg. (In Russian)
14. Chernikova T.V. 2021. «Obratnaja storona» petrovskih reform [The “Flip Side” of Peter the Great's Reforms]. Vestnik Rossijskogo universiteta druzhby narodov. Serija: Istorija Rossii. 20(1). P. 88–107. DOI: 10.22363/2312–8674–2021-20-1-88-107. (In Russian)
15. Chernov O.A. 2001. Diplomaticheskaja dejatel'nost' i istoricheskie vzgljady N.V. Charykova [Diplomatic Activity and Historical Views of N.V. Charykov]. Samara: Publ. house PGSGA. 222 p. (In Russian)
16. Chernov O.A. 2012. Rannie gody rossijskogo diplomata i uchenogo N.V. Charykova. Po dokumentam Central'nogo gosudarstvennogo arhiva Samarskoj oblasti [Early Years of the Russian Diplomat and Scientist N.V. Charykov. According to the documents of the Central State Archives of the Samara Region]. Vestnik arhivista. No4. P. 292–299. (In Russian)
17. Florja B.N. 2019. O russko-avstrijskih politicheskih kontaktah v 70-h godah XVII veka [About the Russian-Austrian Political Contacts in the 70s of the 17th Century]. Istoricheskie zapiski. 18(136). P. 46–56. (In Russian)
18. Jastrebov A.O. 2016. Rossija i venecianskie greki vo vtoroj polovine XVI — vtoroj polovine XVII st. [Russia and the Venetian Greeks in the Second Half of the 16th — Second Half of the 17th Century]. Klio. 8(116). P. 155–163. (In Russian)
19. Klyuchevskij V.O. 1990. Istoricheskie portrety. Deyateli istoricheskoj mysli [Historical Portraits. Figures of Historical Thought]. Moscow: Pravda. (In Russian)
20. Kostomarov N.I. 2009. Istoriya Rossii v zhizneopisaniyah ee glavnejshih deyatelej [The History of Russia in the Biographies of the Most Important Figures]. Moscow: Eksmo. (In Russian)
21. Kuz'micheva L.V. 2021. Rossijskie diplomaty N.V. Charykov i V.N. Shtrandtman o prichinah neudachi rossijskogo plana sozdanija Balkanskoj federacii [Russian Diplomats Nikolai V. Charykov and Vassili N. Strandtmann on the Reasons for the Failure of the Russian Plan to create a Balkan Federation]. Slavjanskij mir v tret'em tysjacheletii. 16(1–2). P. 154–170. DOI: 10.31168/2412–6446.2021.16.1–2.08. (In Russian)
22. Laskova N.V. 2008. Shotlandskoe vlijanie v politicheskoj i povsednevnoj zhizni dopetrovskoj Rusi [Scottish Influence in Political and Everyday Life of Pre-Petrov Rus]. Britanskie issledo-vanija. No2. P. 177–185. (In Russian)
23. Mezin S.A. 2020. Pjotr I i ego jepoha glazami istorikov [Peter I and his era through the Eyes of Historians]. Saratov: Publ. house «Saratovskij istochnik». P. 86–132. (In Russian)
24. Mihajlovskij G.N. 1993. Zapiski. Iz istorii rossijskogo vneshnepoliticheskogo vedomstva. 1914–1920. [Notes. From the History of the Russian Foreign Ministry. 1914–1920]. V 2–h kn. Moscow: Mezhdunarodnye otnosheniya. Kn. 1. (In Russian)
25. Nozdrin O.Ja. 2011. Soldaty Smuty. Naemniki v Rossii nachala XVII v [Soldiers of the Time of Troubles: Mercenaries in Early 17th-century Russia]. Srednie veka. 72(3–4). P. 187–195. (In Russian)
26. Petruhincev N.N. 2017. Rannee evropejskoe vlijanie na Petra I: Patrik Gordon i Franc Lefort v konce XVII v. [Early European Influences on Peter the Great: Patrick Gordon and Franz Lefort at the End of the 17th Century]. Quaestio Rossica. 5(1). P. 198–218. DOI: 10.15826/ qr.2017.1.219. (In Russian)
27. Sedov P.V. 2008. Zakat Moskovskogo carstva: carskij dvor konca XVII veka [The Decline of the Muscovite Kingdom: The Tsar's Court of the Late 17th Century]. 2nd edition. Saint Petersburg: Dmitrij Bulanin. 604 p. (In Russian)
28. Sedov P.V. 2008. Zakat Moskovskogo carstva: carskij dvor konca XVII veka [The Decline of the Moscow Kingdom: the Royal Court of the End of the 17th Century]. 2-e izdanie, ispravlennoe. Saint Petersburg: Dmitrij Bulanin. 604 p. (In Russian)
29. Solov'ev S.M. 1872. Publichnye chteniya o Petre Velikom [Public Readings about Peter the Great]. Moscow: Tipografiya Katkova. (In Russian)
30. Vishnjakov Ja.V. 2021. Dva vzgljada na serbskuju politiku. N.V. Charykov i P. A. Kapnist o vnutripoliticheskom polozhenii Serbskogo korolevstva i Balkan nachala XX veka [Two Views on Serbian Politics. N.V. Charykov and P.A. Kapnist about the Internal Political Situation in the Kingdom of Serbia and in the Balkans at the Beginning of the 20th Century]. Slavjanovedenie. No5. P. 5–15. DOI: 10.31857/S0869544X0016876-6 (In Russian)
Review
For citations:
Chernov O.A. The Epoch and Personality of Peter the Great in Nikolay Charykov’s Research. MGIMO Review of International Relations. 2022;15(5):7-26. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.24833/2071-8160-2022-5-86-7-26
Views:
1107
Email this article 