The Conflicting Soviet Responses to the Lausanne Process (1922-1924)
https://doi.org/10.24833/2071-8160-2023-3-90-81-108
Abstract
The article examines the Soviet responses to the Lausanne Process, which took place from May to November 1923. The process involved the trial of Russian émigrés Moritz Conradi and Arkadii Polunin, who were accused of murdering Vatslav Vatslavovich Vorovskii, the Soviet representative in Italy and head of the delegation to the Lausanne Conference, on May 10, 1923. The acquittal of Conradi and Polunin by a Swiss jury on November 16, 1923, under the verdict of "not guilty," as they were seen as avenging victims of Soviet repression, had a significant impact on the Russian emigration. While the historiography increasingly recognizes the role of various Russian émigrés in turning the trial into a denunciation of Bolshevism, little is known about the Soviet government's response to Vorovskii's killing and the efforts of the People's Commissariat of Foreign Affairs (NKID) to participate in the legal proceedings. By analyzing unpublished letters written by Soviet government officials found in the Archive of Foreign Policy of the Russian Federation and considering the international context of 1923, this study aligns with the historiographic trend that emphasizes collective leadership and institutional autonomy in Soviet foreign policy decisions following Lenin's increasing isolation in late 1922. The research demonstrates that when the Swiss government prevented the Soviet counterpart from participating as a legal party in the process, Moscow resorted to non-traditional foreign projections, which encompassed actions beyond formal diplomacy, and even involved non-communist actors to present the USSR in a positive and "objective" light at Lausanne. However, the bureaucratic complexities of the Soviet state hindered success in court. Thus, the handling of the Lausanne Process by the prosecution serves as an illustrative example of how post-Civil War Soviet institutions operated in relation to one another, characterized by intricate dynamics and an entrenched bureaucracy, far from the alleged "totalitarian" tendencies.
About the Author
R. Matos Franco
National Research University – Higher School of Economics (Saint Petersburg), Russia;
University of Turin, Italy
Italy
Italy
References
1. Aubert T. 1924. Le procès du bolchévisme. L’affaire Conradi : plaidoirie prononcée pour Arcadius Polounine devant le Tribunal criminel de Lausanne, les 14 et 15 novembre 1923. Geneva: Sonor. 132 p. (In French)
2. Bendix R. 1974. Work and Authority in Industry. 2nd ed. Berkeley: University of California Press. 514 p.
3. Bisher J. 2005. White Terror. Cossack Warlords of the Trans-Siberian. London: Routledge. 534 p.
4. Broué P. 2005. The German Revolution 1917–1923. Trad. John Archer. Leiden: Brill. 991 p.
5. Caillat M. 2016. L’Entente internationale anticommuniste de Théodore Aubert. Organisation interne, réseaux et actions d’une internationale antimarxiste, 1924-1950. Lausanne: Société de l’Histoire de la Suisse Romande. 783 p. (In French)
6. Chervonnaya S.A., Evans D.J. 2014. Left Behind: Boris E. Skvirsky and the Chita Delegation at the Washington Conference, 1921–22. Intelligence and National Security. 29(1). P: 19-57. DOI: 10.1080/02684527.2012.746413
7. Conklin A.L. 2013. In the Museum of Man. Race, Anthropology, and Empire in France, 1850–1950. Ithaca: Cornell University Press. 368 p.
8. Conradi M.M. 1923. Traduction de la déclaration de M. Conradi, assassin du diplomate russe V. Vorovski à Lausanne. Diplomatic Documents of Switzerland, 1848-1975. URL: https:// dodis.ch/48619.
9. Detti T. 1987. Fabrizio Maffi. Vita di un medico socialista. Milan: Franco Angeli. 311 p. (In Italian)
10. Fayet J.-F. 2004. Karl Radek (1885–1939). Biographie politique. Bern: Peter Lang. 813 p. Fayet J.-F. 2014. VOKS. Le laboratoire helvétique. Histoire de la diplomatie culturelle soviétique d’entre-deux-guerres. Geneva: Georg. 598 p. (In French)
11. Gattiker A. 1975. L’affaire Conradi. Bern: H. Lang. 323 p. (In French)
12. Graves S. C. 1921. The Truth About Kolchak. Current History. 14(4). P. 668-671. DOI: 10.1525/curh.1921.14P2.1.668
13. Hardeman H. 1994. Coming to Terms with the Soviet Regime. The “Changing Signposts” Movement among Russian Émigrés in the Early 1920s. DeKalb: Northern Illinois University Press. 319 p.
14. Jacobson J. 1994. When the Soviet Union Entered World Politics. Berkeley: University of California Press. 388 p.
15. Matos Franco R. 2021. Socialist Internationalism and National Classifications at the Comintern Schools, 1922–1943. Ab Imperio. No3. P. 136-165. DOI: 10.1353/imp.2021.0056.
16. Matos Franco R. 2023. The Last White Victory. Aleksandr Guchkov and the Conradi – Polunin Process of 1923. Revolutionary Russia. DOI: 10.1080/09546545.2023.2210006.
17. Montandon G. 1921. Mission en Sibérie. 22 mars 1919 – 17 juin 1921. Revue Internationale de la Croix-Rouge. No36. Р. 1197-1232. DOI 10.1017/S102688120006997X. (In French)
18. Montandon G. 1922. Deux ans chez Koltchak et chez les Bolchéviques, pour la Croix-Rouge de Genève (1919–1921). Paris: Félix Alcan. 319 p. (In French)
19. Moore F.F., Skvirskii B.E. & Smith C.H. 1922. The Far Eastern Republic, Siberia, and Japan. Together with a Discussion of Their Relations with the United States. New York: Foreign Policy Association. 17 p.
20. Perrot A. 2020. L’affaire Conradi, un acquittement douteux rendu possible par la minorité de faveur. BA diss., Université de Lausanne. 37 p. (In French)
21. Phillips H.D. 1992. Between the Revolution and the West. A Political Biography of Maxim M. Litvinov. Boulder: Westview Press. 256 p.
22. Ruotsila M. 2010. International Anti-Communism before the Cold War: Success and Failure in the Building of a Transnational Right. M. Durham and M. Power (Eds.). New Perspectives on the Transnational Right. London: Palgrave Macmillan. P. 11-37.
23. Russell B. 1962. The Practice and Theory of Bolshevism. London: Allen & Unwin. 96 p.
24. Senn A.E. 1974. Diplomacy and Revolution. The Soviet Mission to Switzerland, 1918. Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press. 221 p.
25. Senn A.E. 1981. Assassination in Switzerland. The Murder of Vatslav Vorovsky. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press. 220 p.
26. Serge V. 2017. Mémoires d’un révolutionnaire 1905–1945. Montreal: Lux. 632 p. Shlapentokh D. 1995. In Search of Thermidor. International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy. 15 (1-3). P. 1-67. DOI: 10.1108/eb013204
27. Stites R. 1985. Iconoclastic Currents in the Russian Revolution: Destroying and Preserving the Past. In A. Gleason, P. Kenez, & R. Stites (Eds.). Bolshevik Culture. Experiment and Order in the Russian Revolution. Bloomington: Indiana University Press. P. 1-24.
28. Stoeva G. 2019. Posledna vecheria za Vatslav Vorovski i posledstviiata ot negovoto ubiistvo – antibolshevizmŭt kato “bial internatsionalizŭm”. Anamneza. XIV(3). P. 20-30.
29. White S. 2002. The Origins of Détente. The Genoa Conference and Soviet-Western Relations, 1921–1922. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 255 p.
30. Bagotskii S.Iu. .1971. O vstrechakh s Leninym v Pol’she i Shveitsarii. [About Meetings with Lenin in Poland and Switzerland]. Moscow: Politizdat. 72 p. (In Russian)
31. Chistiakov, K.A. 2000. Ubit’ za Rossiiu! Iz istorii russkogo emigrantskogo “aktivizma”: 19181939 gg. [Kill for Russia! From the History of Russian Emigrant “Activism": 1918–1939]. Moscow: Ippolitova. 139 p. (In Russian)
32. Chlenov S.B. 1923. Rech’ po delu ob ubiistve V.V. Vorovskogo [Speech on the Murder of V.V. Vorovsky]. Moscow: Glavlit. 22 p. (In Russian)
33. Dostovalov E.I. .1995. O belykh i belom terrore [About Whites and White Terror].
34. Rossiiskii Arkhiv. Istoria Otechestva v svidetel’stvakh i dokumentakh XVIII–XX vv.: Al’manakh. Moscow: Studia TRITE—Ros. Arkhiv. P. 637-697. (In Russian)
35. Dragunov G. 1989-. Novye fakty o gibeli V.V. Vorovskogo [New Facts about the Death of V.V. Vorovsky]. Mezhdunarodnaia Zhizn’. No4. P. 244-259. (In Russian)
36. Fediukin S.A. 1977. Bor’ba s burzhuaznoi ideologiei v usloviiakh perekhoda k NEPu [The Struggle against Bourgeois Ideology in the Transition to the NEP]. Moscow: Nauka. 350 p. (In Russian)
37. Ganin A. 2019a. “Krasnyi terror” v cherno-belom izobrazhenii ["Red Terror" in Black and White Image]. Rodina. No7. P. 126-129. (In Russian)
38. Ganin A. 2019b. “Tepereshniaia nasha zhizn’ – ne zhizn’, a tol’ko sushchestvovanie...”. Russkie ofitsery v Korolevstve serbov, khorvatov i sloventsev po materialam arkhiva generalleitenanta P.I. Aver’ianova” ["Our Present Life is not Life, but Only Existence...". Russian Officers in the Kingdom of Serbs, Croats and Slovenes Based on the Materials of the Archive of Lieutenant General P.I. Averyanov"]. A. Iu. Timofeev, A. A. Silkin, V. S. Putiatin & M. Zhivanovich (Eds.). Stoletie dvukh emigratsii. 1919-2019. Sbornik statei. Moscow: Institut slavianovedeniia RAN; Belgrade: Informatika. P. 179-192. (In Russian)
39. Genri E. 1981. Professional’nyi antikommunizm. K istorii vozniknoveniia. [Professional Anti-communism. To the History of the Origin]. Moscow: Politizdat. 368 p. (In Russian)
40. Khormach I.A. 1993. Otnosheniia mezhdu sovetskim gosudarstvom i Italiei, 1917-1924 gg. [Relations between the Soviet State and Italy, 1917–1924]. Moscow: IRI RAN. 125 p.
41. Kozlov V.N. 1997. Provokatsiia (Tainaia operatsiia Politbiuro TsK RKP(B) – izdanie smenovekhovskoi gazety. 1922-1924 gg.) [Provocation (Secret Operation of the Politburo of the Central Committee of the RCP (B) – the Publication of the Smenovekhovskaya Newspaper. 1922–1924]. Zvezda. No5. P. 157-160. (In Russian)
42. Kvakin A. 2006. Mezhdu belymi i krasnymi. Russkaia intelligentsia 1920–1930 godov v poiskakh Tret’ego Puti [Between White and Red. The Russian Intelligentsia of 1920–1930 in Search of a Third Way]. Moscow: Tsentrpoligraf. 413 p. (In Russian)
43. Lenin V.I. 1970. Polnoe sobranie sochinenii. [The Complete Works]. T. 44. Moscow: Politizdat. 725 p. (In Russian)
44. Lodyzhenskii Iu.I. 2013. Ot Krasnogo Kresta k bor’be s Kominternom. [From the Red Cross to the Fight against the Comintern]. Moscow: Airis-Press. 576 p. (In Russian)
45. Lukomskii A.S. 2015. Ocherki iz moei zhizni. Vospominaniia [Essays from my Life. Memories]. Moscow and Berlin: DirectMedia. 643 p. (In Russian) MID SSSR [Ministry of Foreign Affairs of The USSR]. 1962. Dokumenty Vneshnei Politiki SSSR, T. 6 (20 noiabria 1922 g. – 31 dekabria 1923 g.). Moscow: Politizdat. 671 p. (In Russian)
46. Rossiiskaia Kommunisticheskaia Partiia (Bol’sheviki) [The Russian Communist Party (Bolsheviks)]. 1922. Materialy Vserossiiskoi Partiinoi Konferentsii, 4-7 avgusta 1922 g. Tula: Izd. Agitpropotdela Tulgubkoma. 98 p. (In Russian)
47. Rossiiskoe Obshchestvo Krasnogo Kresta [Russian Red Cross Society]. 1925. Russkii Krasnyi Krest posle 1917 goda: ocherk deiatel’nosti Rossiiskago obshchestva Krasnago Kresta (staroi organizatsii). Paris: Rapid. 40 p. (In Russian)
48. Sergeev E.Iu. 2019. Bol’sheviki i anglichane. Sovetsko-britanskie otnosheniia, 1918-1924 gg. Ot interventsii k priznaniiu [The Bolsheviks and the British. Soviet-British Relations, 1918–1924 From Intervention to Recognition]. Saint Petersburg: Nauka. 832 p. (In Russian)
49. Sevost’ianov G.N. (Ed.). 2002. Moskva – Rim. Politika i diplomatiia Kremlia 1920-1939 [Moscow – Rome. Kremlin politics and Diplomacy (1920–1939)]. Moscow: Nauka. 483 p. (In Russian)
50. Sheinis Z.S. 1989. Maksim Maksimovich Litvinov. Revoliutsioner, diplomat, chelovek [Maxim Maksimovich Litvinov. A Revolutionary, a Diplomat, a Person]. Moscow: Politizdat. 432 p. (In Russian)
51. Shkarenkov, L.K. 1987. Agoniia beloi emigratsii [The Agony of White Emigration]. Moscow: Mysl’. 239 p. (In Russian)
Review
For citations:
Franco R.M. The Conflicting Soviet Responses to the Lausanne Process (1922-1924). MGIMO Review of International Relations. 2023;16(3):81-108. https://doi.org/10.24833/2071-8160-2023-3-90-81-108
Views:
590
Email this article 