THE CONCEPT OF THE «BLACK HUNDREDS» IN THE SOVIET HISTORICAL SCIENCE: RUNNING IN CIRCLES
https://doi.org/10.24833/2071-8160-2016-3-48-88-101
Abstract
During the Soviet period, the right monarchism was considered by historians of our country as part of general methodological approaches to the study of non-proletarian parties. As ideological and political antagonist of Bolshevism, the Black Hundreds were interpreted as the most reactionary political movement of pre-revolutionary Russia. As a result, the full scientific debate on the right monarchism in the Soviet period did not take place, and Soviet historians failed to form a historical concept of the Black Hundreds as an ideological and political trend in the early twentieth century.
About the Author
G. A. Ivakin
The Russian Presidential Academy of National Economy and Public Administration (RANEPA)
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Doctor of Historical Sciences, Department of educational policy, Deputy Chief,
82/5 Prospect Vernadskogo, Moscow, 119571
References
1. Avreh A.Ja. III Duma i nachalo krizisa tret'eijun'skoj sistemy (1908–1909) [The Third Duma and the beginning of crisis for the system of 3rd June]. Istoricheskie zapiski. RAN SSSR. 1955. T. 53. pp. 50-109
2. Avreh A.Ja. Agrarnyj vopros v tret'ej Dume [Rural problems in the Third Duma]. Istoricheskie zapiski. 1958. №63. pp. 26-83
3. Avreh A.Ja. Carizm i tret'eijun'skaja sistema [Tsarism and the system of 3rd June]. Moscow: Nauka, 1966.
4. Avreh A.Ja. Carizm nakanune sverzhenija [Tsarism before being ousted]. Moscow: Nauka, 1989.
5. Bazhin A.A. Bor'ba partii bol'shevikov protiv chernosotennogo dvizhenija v gody Pervoj russkoj revoljucii (1905–1907 gg.) [Bolshevik party struggle against far-right during World War I]: PhD in History thesis. Moscow, 1979.
6. Barandov G.V. Stolypinskaja reakcija [Oppresion under Stolypin]. Moscow: Gosudarstvennoe izd-vo polit. lit-ry, 1938.
7. Bondarenko K.M. Russkie i belorusskie monarhisty v literature 20–30-h gg. proshlogo veka [Russian and bielorussian monarchists in literature of 1920-1930]. Białoruskie Zeszyty Historyczne, Belaruskі gіstarychny zbornіk. 2011. №35. S. 127-139
8. Volobuev P.V., Lejberov I.P. Prolog Oktjabrja. K 50-letiju Fevral'skoj burzhuazno-demokraticheskoj revoljucii [Before the October. To 50th anniversary of the February bourgeois democratic revolution] .Kommunist. 1959. № 3.
9. GARF. F. 116. Op. 1. D. 23. L. 43–43ob. Doklad predsedatelja Akkermanskogo otdela Sojuza russkogo naroda k utverzhdennoj programme soveshhanij s’ezda v g. Nizhnem Novgorode 26 nojabrja 1915 g. [Report of the chairmain for Accerman division of the Union of the Russian People on the adopted agenda of the Union’s convention, 26 November 1915]
10. GARF. F. 116. Op. 2. D. 77. L. 1ob.
11. Gorovskij F.Ja. Bor'ba bol'shevikov za razreshenie nacional'nogo voprosa v gody revoljucionnogo pod’ema (po materialam IV Gosudarstvennoj dumy) [Bolshevik’s struggle for national problems resolution in the years of revolutionary boost]. Moscow, 1950.
12. Gosudarstvennaja duma. Stenograficheskie otchety. Sozyvy pervyj – chetvertyj [State Duma. Full texts of speeches. 1-4 tenure]. Sanct-Petersberg, 1906–1917.
13. Demin V.T. Social-demokraticheskaja frakcija bol'shevikov v IV Gosudarstvennoj dume (1912–1914 gg.) [Social-democratic bolshevik faction in the 4th Duma] . Moscow, 1947.
14. Djakin V.S. Burzhuazija, dvorjanstvo i carizm v 1911–1914 godah: razlozhenie tret'eijun'skoj sistemy [the bourgeoisie, the nobility and tsarism in 1911-1914: decline of the system of 3rd June]. Leningrad: Nauka, 1988.
15. Djakin V.S. Samoderzhavie: burzhuazija i dvorjanstvo [The absolute monarchy: the bourgeoisie and the nobility]. Leningrad, 1978.
16. Zavadskaja L.V. Agrarnyj vopros v I Gosudarstvennoj dume i bor'ba bol'shevikov za krest'janstvo [The rural problems in the 1st Duma and the bolshevik struggle for the peasantry]. Bol'sheviki vo glave Pervoj russkoj revoljucii 1905–1907 godov. Ed. by F. D. Kretova (gl. red.) [i dr.]. Moscow, 1956. pp. 431-438
17. Zaslavskij D.O. Rycar' monarhii Shul'gin [The Monarchial Knight Shulgin]. Moscow: Priboj, 1927.
18. Zevelev A.I., Sviridenko Ju.P., Pavlov D.B., Stepanskij A.D. Teoretiko-metodologicheskie, istoriograficheskie i arheograficheskie aspekty [Theoretical and methodological, historiographical and archeographic aspects]. Politicheskie partii Rossii: istorija i sovremennost'. M.: ROSSPJeN, 2000. pp. 5-66
19. Zelenov M.V. Spechran i istoricheskaja nauka v Sovetskoj Rossii v 1920–1930-e gody [Special savings and historical science in Soviet Russia in 1920-1930]. Otechestvennaja istorija. 2000. № 2. pp. 129-141
20. Ivanova A.I. Iz opyta bor'by kazanskih bol'shevikov protiv ideologii chernosotenstva v revoljucii 1905–1907 gg. [Kazan’s bolsheviks’ experience in fighting against far-right ideology in 1905-1907]. Obshhestvennye otnoshenija razvitogo socializma: (Vopr. teorii i istorii stanovlenija i sovershenstvovanija) / [Redkol.: Shhelkunov M. D. (otv. red.) i dr.). Kazan': Izd-vo Kazan. un-ta, 1985.
21. Ioffe G.3. Krah rossijskoj monarhicheskoj kontrrevoljucii [The collapse of Russian monarchic counter-revolution]. Moscow, 1977.
22. Istorija Vsesojuznoj kommunisticheskoj partii (bol'shevikov). Kratkij kurs [History of All-Russian Comminist Party (bolsheviks). The short course]. pod red. komissii CK VKP(b). Moscow: Pravda, 1938.
23. Kandidov B.P. Krestom i nagajkoj: Pochaevskaja lavra i chernosotennoe dvizhenie [Pochaivskaya Lawra and far-right movement]. Moscow, 1928.
24. Kandidov B.P. Cerkov' v 1905 godu (ocherki i materialy) [The church in 1905]. Moscow, 1930.
25. Karpuhin D.V. Otechestvennaja istoriografija chernosotennyh sojuzov i organizacij [Russian historiography of far-right unions and organizations]. PhD in History thesis. Moscow, 2008.
26. Kir'janov Ju.I. Pravye partii v Rossii. 1911–1917 gg. [Right parties in Russia. 1911-1917]. Moscow, 2001.
27. Kiselev I.N., Korelin A.P., Shelohaev V.V. Politicheskie partii v Rossii v 1905–1907 godah: chislennost', sostav, razmeshhenie [Political parties in Russia in 1905-1907: numbers, structure, location]. Istorija SSSR. 1990. № 4. pp. 71-87
28. Kicheev V.G. Istoriografija chernosotenno-monarhicheskih organizacij v Rossii v nachale XX veka [Historiography of far-right organizations in Russia at the beginning of XX century]. Vestnik Tomskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. 2008. № 315. pp. 88-95
29. Kicheev V.G. Sovetskaja istoriografija chernosotenno-monarhicheskih organizacij v Rossii v nachale XX veka [Soviet historiography of far-right organizations in Russia at the beginning of XX century]. Irkutskij istoriko-jekonomicheskij ezhegodnik. Irkutsk: Izd-vo BGUJeP, 2007. pp. 33-40
30. Koval'chuk M.A. Bol'sheviki v tret'ej Gosudarstvennoj dume [Bolsheviks in the 3rd Duma]. Leningrad, 1950.
31. Kogan I. Karatel'nye jekspedicii [Punishing operations]. Moscow, 1925.
32. Komin V.V. Bankrotstvo burzhuaznyh partij v Rossii v period podgotovki i pobedy Velikoj Oktjabr'skoj socialisticheskoj revoljucii [Bankruptcy of bourgeois parties in Russia during the period before the Great October socialist Revolution]. Moscow, 1965.
33. Komin V.V. Istorija pomeshhich'ih, burzhuaznyh i melkoburzhuaznyh politicheskih partij v Rossii. Fakul'tativnyj kurs lekcij dlja studentov istoricheskogo fakul'teta pedagogicheskogo instituta. Ch. I (1900 – ijun' 1917 gg.) [The history of nobleman, bourgeois and little- bourgeois political parties in Russia. Additional course. Part I]. Kalinin, 1970.
34. Koroleva N.G. Pomeshhich'e-monarhicheskie organizacii v 1905–1907 godah [Landowners’ and monarchist organizations in 1905-1907]. Obrazovanie, struktura, taktika. Neproletarskie partii Rossii v treh revoljucijah / Ed. by K.V. Gusev. Moscow: Nauka, 1989. pp. 101-104
35. Kostomarov G.D. Chernaja sotnja pod flagom religii [Far-right allies with religion]. Moscow, 1931.
36. Krizis samoderzhavija v Rossii [The crisis of autocrat monarchy in Russia]. Leningrad: Nauka, 1984.
37. Lenin V.I. Stolypin i revoljucija [Stolypin and the revolution]. Polnoe sobranie sochinenij. Izd. pjatoe. T. 20. Moscow: Izd-vo polit. lit-ry, 1973. pp. 324-333
38. Lukojanov I.V. Djakin kak istorik [Dyakin as a historian]. Na puti k revoljucionnym potrjasenijam: iz istorii Rossii vtoroj poloviny XIX – nachala XX veka: materialy konferencii pamjati V.S. Djakina / RAN In-t ros. ist. SPb. fil.; RAN In-t ros. ist. SPb. fil. Sanct-Petersberg-Kishinev: Nestor-Historia, 2001. pp. 29-37
39. Ljubosh S.B. Russkij fashist Vladimir Purishkevich [Russian fashist Vladimir Purishkevich]. Leningrad, 1925.
40. Mazis S.M. Vopros o strahovanii rabochih v III Gosudarstvennoj dume i strahovaja kampanija 1912–1914 godov [The issue of labour insurance in 3rd Duma and the campaign for insurance in 1912-1914]. Moscow, 1952.
41. Monarhija pered krusheniem. Bumagi Nikolaja II i drugie dokumenty [Monarchy before bapticising. Nikolay the Second’s papers]. Moscow-Leningrad, 1927.
42. Neproletarskie partii Rossii v gody burzhuazno-demokraticheskih revoljucij i v period nazrevanija socialisticheskoj revoljucii: materialy konferencii [Non-proletarian parties during bourgeois democratic revolutions and preparing for the socialist revolution]. Ed by akad. I.I. Minc. Moscow, 1982.
43. Neproletarskie partii Rossii v treh revoljucijah [Non-proletarian parties under three revolutions]. Ed by K.V. Gusev. Moscow: Nauka, 1989.
44. Neproletarskie partii Rossii. Urok istorii [Non-proletarian. Historical lessons]. Moscow: Mysl', 1984.
45. Nechkina M.V. A.S. Griboedov i dekabristy [Griboedov and the Decembrists]. Moscow: Goslitizdat, 1947.
46. Nechkina M.V. Vosstanie 14 dekabrja 1825 goda [The upprising of 14 December 1825]. Moscow: Izd-vo AN SSSR, 1951.
47. Ol'hovskij M.Z. Vnutridumskaja dejatel'nost' bol'shevistskoj frakcii IV Gosudarstvennoj dumy [Inner-Parliamentary activities of bolshevik faction in 4th Duma]. Moscow, 1952.
48. Orlov I.B. Istorik stalinskoj jepohi na «fronte istoricheskoj nauki» [Historian of the Stalinist era on the front of historical science]. Har'kivskij istoriografichnij zbirnik. Vip. 11. H.: HNU imeni Karazina, 2012. pp. 117-130
49. Pankratova A.M. Pervaja russkaja revoljucija 1905–1907 godov [The First Russian Revolution, 1905-1907]. Moscow: Politizdat, 1940
50. Popov F.K. Popy-chernosotency. Ivanovo-Voznesensk, 1932.
51. Rostov N.M. Duhovenstvo i russkaja kontrrevoljucija konca dinastii Romanovyh [The clergy and the Russian counter-revolution at the end of Romanov’s era]. Moscow, 1930.
52. Russkie v XX veke [the Russians in XX century]. Moscow: OLMA Media Grupp, 2004.
53. Rylov V.Ju. Pravoe dvizhenie v Voronezhskoj gubernii (1903–1917) [Right movements in Voronezh region]. Voronezh, 2002.
54. Semennikov V.P. Monarhija pered krusheniem 1914–1917: bumagi Nikolaja II i drugie dokumenty [The monarcy before the colapse in 1914-1917: Nikolay the Second’s papers]. Moscow-Leningrad, 1927.
55. Slepkov A.N. Klassovye protivorechija v I Gosudarstvennoj dume [The class divisions in 1st Duma]. Ed. by M.N. Pokrovskiy. Sanct-Petersburg, 1923.
56. Sojuz russkogo naroda. Po materialam Chrezvychajnoj sledstvennoj komissii Vremennogo pravitel'stva v 1917 godu [The Union of the Russian people. Materials of the Urgent investigational commission in 1917]. sost. A. Chernovskij; red. i vstup. st. V.P. Viktorova. Moscow-Leningrad, 1929.
57. Spirin L.M. Eshhe raz o teoretiko-metodologicheskih voprosah izuchenija istorii neproletarskih partij Rossii [Once again on the theoretical and methodological issues of Russian non-proletarian parties’ history]. Neproletarskie partii Rossii v gody burzhuazno-demokraticheskih revoljucij i v period nazrevanija socialisticheskoj revoljucii: materialy konferencii. Ed. by akad. I.I. Minc. Moscow, 1982. pp. 3-10
58. Spirin L.M. Krushenie pomeshhich'ih i burzhuaznyh partij v Rossii (nachalo XX v. – 1920 g.) [The collapse of ladowners’ and bourgeois parties in Russia]. Moscow: Mysl', 1977.
59. Stenograficheskie otchety doprosov i pokazanij, dannyh v 1917 g. v Chrezvychajnoj sledstvennoj komissii Vremennogo pravitel'stva [Full texts ofinterrogation and statements of the Urgent investigational commission in 1917]. T. 1–7. Moscow-Leningrad, 1924–1927.
60. Stepanov S.A. Bankrotstvo agrarnoj programmy chernosotennyh sojuzov [The bankruptcy of agrarian agenda of far-right parties]. Jakutsk: Jakut. fil. Sib. otd. AN SSSR, 1981.
61. Stepanov S.A. Ideologija chernosotennyh sojuzov i organizacij [The ideology of far-right unions and organizations]. Problemy istorii SSSR. M., 1982. Vyp. 12. S. 170-182
62. Stepanov S.A. Programmy chernosotennyh organizacij (1905–1907 gg.) [Programs of far-right orfanizaions in 1905-1917]. Neproletarskie partii Rossii v treh revoljucijah. Moscow, 1989. pp. 105-111
63. Stepanov S.A. Chernaja sotnja. Chto oni sdelali dlja velichija Rossii? [The Black hundred. What did the do for Russian greatness?] Moscow: Jauza-Press, 2013.
64. Stecenko A.I., Tochenyj D.S. Chernosotency Povolzh'ja v 1905 godu (k istorii bor'by social-demokratii s pogromami pravyh monarhistov) [Far-rightist in the Volga region]. Klassovaja bor'ba v Povolzh'e v 1905–1907 godah. Kujbyshev, 1985. pp. 84-89
65. Stogov D.I. Chernosotency: zhizn' i smert' za velikuju Rossiju [The Black Hundred: life and death for the great Russia]. Ed. by O.A. Platonov. Moscow: Algoritm, 2012.
66. Sysoeva E.K. Politika ideologicheskogo vozdejstvija chernosotennyh partij na rabochih v gody Pervoj russkoj revoljucii: po materialam Moskvy i Moskovskoj gubernii: PhD in History Thesis [Far-right parties ideological policy towards proletarians during the Fisrt Russian Revolution]. Moscow, 1978.
67. Tager A.S. Carskaja Rossija i delo Bejlisa [Tsarist Russia and Bejlis’ case]. 2-e izd. Moscow, 1934.
68. Tamarkina B.M. Partija bol'shevikov v period Pervoj russkoj revoljucii [Bolshevik party during the First Russian Revolution]. Moscow, 1958.
69. Telicyn V.L. Pavel Vasil'evich Volobuev (1923–1997). Istoriki Rossii: poslevoennoe pokolenie. Moscow: AIROHH, 2000. pp. 57–78
70. Titlinov V.P. Pravoslavie na sluzhbe samoderzhavija: iz istorii revoljucionnogo dvizhenija uchashhejsja molodezhi duhovnyh i srednih uchebnyh zavedenij, 1860–1905 gody [The Orthodoxy service to autocrat monarchy: from the history of revolutionary movement of students of religious and middle-level schools]. Leningrad, 1924.
71. Titlinov V.P. Cerkov' vo vremja revoljucii [The Church during the Revolution]. Sanct-Petersburg, 1924.
72. Tihonov V.V. Istoricheskaja nauka v 1920-e gody: istoriograficheskie zametki [Historical science in 1920-1929: historiographic notes]. Vestnik Cheljabinskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. 2013. № 30 (321). pp. 101-108
73. Tomsinskij S.G. Bor'ba klassov i partij v pervoj Gosudarstvennoj dume [Class fighting and parties in the 1st Duma]. Rostov on the Done, 1924.
74. Chemerisskij I.A. Istoriografija pravomonarhicheskih organizacij (1905–1920) [Historiography of right monarchic organization in 1905-1920]. Neproletarskie partii Rossii v gody burzhuazno-demokraticheskih revoljucij i v period nazrevanija socialisticheskoj revoljucii: materialy konferencii. Ed. by akad. I.I. Minc. Moscow, 1982. S. 66-73
75. Chermenskij E.D. Bor'ba partij i klassov v IV Gosudarstvennoj dume (1912–1917 gg.) [Class fighting and parties in the 4th Duma]. Moscow, 1947.
76. Chermenskij E.D. Burzhuazija i carizm v revoljucii 1905–1907 godov [The bourgeoisie and tsarism in revolution 1905-1907]. Moscow-Leningrad, 1939.
77. 1905 god. Istorija revoljucionnogo dvizhenija v otdel'nyh ocherkah. Istpart CK RKP(b) [History of revolutionary movement in certain articles]. Ed. by M.N. Pokrovskiy. T. 2. Moscow-Leningrad: GIZ, 1925.
78. Vdovin A.I. Russkij narod i problemy formirovanija sovetskoj istoricheskoj obshhnosti (1930-e gg.). [Electronic resource]. Mode of access: http://www.portal-slovo.ru/history/41178.php
79. Raboty E.D. Chermenskogo o problemah Fevral'skoj revoljucii i ee predposylkah. Mezhdu dvuh revoljucij. 1905–1917 [Electronic resource]. Ezhekvartal'nyj zhurnal istorii i kul'tury Rossii i Vostochnoj Evropy «NESTOR». 2000. № 3. Mode of access: http://secrethistory.su/1324-raboty-ed-chermenskogo-o-problemah-fevralskoyrevolyucii-i-ee-predposylkah.html
80. Shanin T. Uroki istorii i sledujushhaja revoljucija: granicy politicheskogo voobrazhenija [Electronic resource]. Otechestvennye zapiski. 2002. Vyp. № 4–5 (5–6). Mode of access: http://www.strana-oz.ru/2002/4/urokiistorii-i-sleduyushchaya-revolyuciya-granicy-politicheskogo-voobrazheniya.
Review
For citations:
Ivakin G.A. THE CONCEPT OF THE «BLACK HUNDREDS» IN THE SOVIET HISTORICAL SCIENCE: RUNNING IN CIRCLES. MGIMO Review of International Relations. 2016;(3(48)):88-101. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.24833/2071-8160-2016-3-48-88-101
Views:
989
Email this article 