Issues of International and Interchurch Relations in the Work of Holy Council 1917–1918 of the Orthodox Russian Church

The convocation of the Local Council in 1917, the first Council in over two centuries, had a great significance for the internal life of the Orthodox Church of Russia. But in a period when the World War was still ongoing and there were pressing issues to resolve in the sphere of cooperation of Russian Orthodoxy with other orthodox and non-orthodox churches, the Local Council could not but touch upon the international and inter-church issues. For the first time in the history of Russian Church the official ecclesiastical forum was attended by official elected delegates who served abroad and who could bring the opinion of the foreign part of the Russian Church to its «maternal» part and to provide the mutually beneficial exchange of practices and opinions. Moreover, in a situation when the church was liberated from the tutelage of the state, it became possible to engage with foreign religious organizations not through social organizations or the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, but directly. This opened a way for creating the Church’s own structures which would be responsible for contacts with other confessions, including Old-Catholics and Anglicans, with whom there had already been lengthy unofficial dialogue. The efforts of some historians and publicists shaping contemporary discourse in Russia depict the restoration of the Patriarchate in the Russian Church as the only important act of the Council are challenged by the material presented in this article, which shows how the Council constructed the future position of Russian Orthodoxy in dialogue with the non-Orthodox churches, in its presence abroad and its missions in non-Christian countries. The word of the Council in this sphere was completely new and never before told. The Council was ahead of its time in the issues of international connections (like in many other spheres of its work). Many issues at the Council were expressed for the first time or in a completely new way. How to manage the missions abroad (in Japan, China, Korea, Urmia, and Palestine)? The Council, occupied with the internal problems in the situation of the beginning of persecution against it, could not abandon these missions. How was it possible to unite Russian emigrants abroad? The idea of Paris as a centre of their unification was expressed for the first time at the Council. The scholars who touched upon these issues before analyzed them through the concept of ecumenism (following the participation of the Russian Church in the ecumenical movement). But it seems more appropriate to research them in the context of the time of the Council itself, since it was a time that preceded the emergence of the Ecumenical Movement proper. The author of the article draws a conclusion that during the year of the Council (August 1917 – September 1918) the issues of international and inter-church relationships transformed in its agenda from being of secondary to primary importance. This conclusion allows us to challenge the dismissive perspective that the Moscow Council 1917-1918 was ineffective. Although it did not have time to complete its agenda, the Council was ahead of its time and contributed much for the future mission of the Russian Church in the modern world.

Russian Orthodox Church, Local Council, Anglicans, old-catholic movement, Tikhon (Bellavin), Evdokim (Mescherskiy), A.V. Kartashev, I. P. Sokolov, I. I. Sokolov, ecumenism, Christian unity

1. Besstremjannaja G. E. Kontakty Russkoj duhovnoj missii v Koree i Japonskoj Pravoslavnoj Cerkvi v 1896–1946 gody [Contacts between Russian spiritual mission in Korea and Japanese Orthodox Church in 1896–1946]. Cerkov' i vremja [Church and time]. 2009, no. 2 (47), pp. 113–215. (In Rus-sian).

2. Galkina Ju. M. Francuzskij zhurnalist Rene Marshan: neskol'ko shtrihov k portretu «druga sovetskoj Rossii» [French journalist René Marchand: a few strokes to the portrait of “a friend of Soviet Russia”]. Vestnik RUDN. Serija «Istorija Rossii». 2019, vol. 18, no. 1, pp. 85–100. (In Russian)

3. Destivel' Iakinf, svjashhennik. Pomestnyj Sobor Rossijskoj Pravoslavnoj Cerkvi 1917–1918 gg. i princip sobornosti [Destivelle Hyacinthe, priest. The Local Council of the Russian Orthodox Church of 1917–1918 and the principle of conciliarity]. Moscow, 2008. 307 p. (In Russian)

4. Dokumenty Svjashhennogo Sobora Pravoslavnoj Rossijskoj Cerkvi 1917–1918 godov. T. 1. Predsobornaja rabota 1917 goda. Akty, opredeljavshie porjadok sozyva i provedenija Sobora [Documents of the Holy Council of the Orthodox Russian Church in 1917–1918. Volume 1. Preconciliar work of 1917. Acts that regulated the procedure of convening and the work of the Council]. Moscow, 2012. 1376 p. (In Russian)

5. Dokumenty Svjashhennogo Sobora Pravoslavnoj Rossijskoj Cerkvi 1917–1918 godov. T. 5. Dejanija Sobora s 1-go po 36-e / otv. red. svjashhennik Aleksij Kolcherin, A.I. Mramornov. [Documents of the Holy Council of the Orthodox Russian Church, 1917–1918. Volume 5. The Acts (stenograms) of the Council from the 1st to the 36th. Edited by priest Alexei Kolcherin and A.I. Mramornov]. Moscow, 2015. 938 p. (In Russian).

6. Kon' R.M. Braki s inoslavnymi i sektantami v Rossii po dokumentam podgotovki Pomestnogo Sobora 1917–1918 godov [Marriages with non-Orthodox and sectarians in Russia according to the documents of preparation of the Local Council of 1917–1918]. Bogoslovskij vestnik. 2017, no, 24–25, issue 1–2, pp. 305–348. (In Russian).

7. Kosik V. I., Shestakov A. V. Varnava (Rosich Petar), mitr. Belgradsko-Karlovackij i Patriarh Serbskij [Varnava (Rosic Petar), metropolitan of Belgrad-Karlovci]. Pravoslavnaja jenciklopedija. Moscow, 2003, vol. 6, pp. 648–649. (In Russian)

8. Kraveckij A. G. Cerkovnaja missija v epohu peremen (mezhdu propoved'ju i dialogom) [Church mission in the times of changes (among preaching and dialogue)]. Moscow, 2012. 712 p. (In Russian)

9. Lepilin A. V. Vzaimodejstvie Russkoj Pravoslavnoj Cerkvi s jekumenicheskim dvizheniem v period ego zarozhdenija i razvitija (1917–1961). Avtoreferat dissertatsii ... kandidata istoricheskih nauk. [The cooperation of the Russian Orthodox Church with the ecumenical movement in the period of its birth and development (1917–1961). Essay of the dissertation of the candidate of historical sciences] Orel, 2004. (In Russian)

10. Suhanova N. A. Istorija Japonskoj Pravoslavnoj Cerkvi v XX veke: put' k avtonomii. [History of the Japanese Orthodox Church in the 20th century: the way to autonomy]. Saint Petersburg, 2013. 418 p. (In Russian)

11. Toropov D.A. Pervyj etap peregovorov predstavitelej Rossijskoj Pravoslavnoj Cerkvi so starokatolikami (1871–1875 gg.). [The first period of the negotiations between the representatives of the Russian Orthodox Church and the Old Catholic movement (1871–1875)]. Cerkovno-istoricheskij vestnik. Moscow, 2009–2010, no. 16–17, pp. 47–54. (In Russian).

12. Toropov D.A. Komandirovki predstavitelej Rossijskoj Pravoslavnoj Cerkvi na starokatolicheskie konferencii i kongressy (1871-1913) [Visits of representatives of the Russian Orthodox Church to Old Catholic conferences and congresses (1871–1913)]. Cerkov' i vremja. 2014, no. 4 (69), pp. 188–206. (In Russian).

13. Fedotov S.P., Novikov V.F., Merkulov A.V. Politicheskie faktory i posledstvija moskovskoj vstrechi pravoslavnyh i anglikan v 1943 godu [Political factors and consequences of the Moscow meeting of Orthodox and Anglicans in 1946]. Srednerusskij vestnik obshhestvennyh nauk. 2018, vol. 13, no 4, pp. 118–133. (In Russian).

14. Shevchenko T.I. Pomestnyj Sobor Pravoslavnoj Rossijskoj Cerkvi 1917–1918 gg. o polozhenii pravoslavnyh v Finlyandii [The Local Council of the Russian Church 1917-1918 about the status of the orthodox people in Finland]. Vestnik PSTGU. Istoriya. Istoriya Russkoj Pravoslavnoj Cerkvi. 2011, no. 6 (43), pp. 85–116. (In Russian).

15. Dunn D. J. The Catholic Church and Soviet Russia, 1917–1939. London – New York, 2017. 142 p.

16. Fitzgerald Th. E. The ecumenical movement: an introductory history. Westport, 2004. 276 p.

17. Schulz G. Das Landeskonzil der Orthodoxen Kirche in Rußland — ein unbekanntes Reformpotential. Göttingen, 1995. 212 S. (In German).

18. Schulz G. Der Ausschuß für die Vereinigung der Kirchen des Landeskonzils der Orthodoxen Kirche in Rußland 3./16.8. bis 7./20.9.1918. Kirche im Osten. 1996, Bd. 39, S. 70–100. (In German)